Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Pesticides
In article , Martin
writes On Tue, 23 Apr 2013 10:33:56 +0100, news wrote: In article , Martin writes It didn't say that. It was typical BBC dumbed down science. Whereas other channels don't do that? Sounds like another boring BBC bashing. Especially if you snip the context. I saw no context that would explain why it should be 'typical BBC dumbed down science' as opposed to 'typical TV dumbed down science' [little snip] The whole programme would be better if Countryfile didn't constantly switch between topics and then have to recap what had been said earlier. This is common in BBC programmes I find it very irritating, the BBC probably think it is entertaining. It is a peak time magzine programme with a Sunday pm audience profile - and without time to go into depth on the science, I presume. Even the dedicated science programmes have to take a balance between people that know nothing of the subject and experts that will view it as dumbed down. Dedicated science programmes do not have to be for everybody. But Countryfile does Anyway, I was intending to refer to 'close to' peak time, often science-based documentaries. Their presentation can run a gamut from highly technical, the details of which may well be beyond the average reasonably intelligent person - to technical that is presented in such a way as to inform that same person. I've seen both. Some programmes are made that do neither - although probably fewer of them on BBC than elsewhere. Some programmes that ostensibly include scientific explanations are dreadful, completely failing to set the scene or address any reasonable doubts as to the conclusions. I think they are more often bad programmes rather than dumbed down - and again, I think you'll find more of them not on the BBC. But it looks like we're not likely to agree on this. Not that I'm disagreeing that a lot of it could still be called dumbed down - but the nature of the programme/slot will vary this - and moreover, I don't see much different on non-BBC programmes. There isn't any difference. There should be. Commercial stations need high viewing numbers otherwise they don't attract advertisers and income. The BBC gets income whatever it shows. Only in a very superfical way. If it doesn't get the viewers, it has problems justifying the funding. And its usually under the sort of pressure from BBC haters that means its damned whether it does or it doesn't. The BBC used to set standards. And what if you set the standards but everyone chooses to ignore them? Would you still get the funding? It is not obliged to target those with the lowest intelligence or poor education. I don't think it necessarily does but there are horses for courses. Countryfile is a peaktime Sunday slot with a magazine style covering a wide range of items. It might not get everything right, but what always does? 80-90% of BBC programmes are repeats. They have plenty of time to show serious science programmes. Countryfile spent a lot of time on pesticides and bees, and recapping what had been said earlier in the programme. It wouldn't have taken much time to have given a more balanced view of the problem, but of course saying that 5% of bees deaths can be attributed to pesticides is neither dramatic nor entertaining. They might have least got the facts right about the proposed EU Commissioners pesticide ban, which was rejected by EU member states at the beginning of March I don't deny that there is dumbed down science. But I do dispute the impression given that it is the BBC that needs to be blamed for typical dumbed down science. -- regards andyw |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Pests, Pesticides and GMO regulations (fwd) | sci.agriculture | |||
Advice on growing roses without pesticides | North Carolina | |||
Pesticides and farm kids | sci.agriculture | |||
Compost--Heat and Herbicides/Pesticides | Gardening | |||
Biosociopathic Injury: Pesticides blamed in decline of 3 additional frog species | alt.forestry |