GardenBanter.co.uk

GardenBanter.co.uk (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/)
-   United Kingdom (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/)
-   -   Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning? (https://www.gardenbanter.co.uk/united-kingdom/53215-why-do-people-collect-mushrooms-early-morning.html)

Chris 21-02-2004 06:02 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris

Janet Bennett 21-02-2004 06:51 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris




Janet Bennett 21-02-2004 06:51 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris




JennyC 21-02-2004 08:12 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


One feels inclined to answer, 'because they go so well with the egg bacon and
sausage.....'

But it's probably as they are then at their freshest. One site suggests they are
easier to see in the early light, while another says 'only mad dogs and
Englishmen go out in the mid day sun'

Jenny :~)



Franz Heymann 21-02-2004 08:34 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.

Franz



Mary Fisher 21-02-2004 10:41 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Franz Heymann" wrote in message
...

"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't

be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.


Dafter answer still: because if they weren't they wouldn't legally be
allowed to be described as 'morning gathered'.

Mary

Franz





Mary Fisher 21-02-2004 11:22 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Franz Heymann" wrote in message
...

"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't

be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.


Dafter answer still: because if they weren't they wouldn't legally be
allowed to be described as 'morning gathered'.

Mary

Franz





Mary Fisher 21-02-2004 11:22 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Franz Heymann" wrote in message
...

"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't

be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.


Dafter answer still: because if they weren't they wouldn't legally be
allowed to be described as 'morning gathered'.

Mary

Franz





Jaques d'Alltrades 22-02-2004 12:19 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from "Franz Heymann" contains these words:
"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...


Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.


You have hit on the correct one, however daft you might think it.

--
Rusty
Open the creaking gate to make a horrid.squeak, then lower the foobar.
http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/hi-fi/

Larry Stoter 22-02-2004 09:45 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Chris ] wrote:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?


I don't, necessarily.

In fact, collecting them early can be a bad idea - if there has been a
heavy dew, they'll be wet, which results in them tending to go off very
quickly and/or not cook very well.

Generally though, mushrooms first emerge overnight and, as has been
mentioned, if you aren't first, you won't get any. Although, several
varieties - parasol, cep - can take several days to mature. If you're
sure nobody else is going to grab them, it is usually best to wait.
--
Larry Stoter

martin 22-02-2004 10:12 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 09:40:55 +0000, (Larry
Stoter) wrote:

Chris ] wrote:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?


I don't, necessarily.

In fact, collecting them early can be a bad idea - if there has been a
heavy dew, they'll be wet, which results in them tending to go off very
quickly and/or not cook very well.

Generally though, mushrooms first emerge overnight and, as has been
mentioned, if you aren't first, you won't get any. Although, several
varieties - parasol, cep - can take several days to mature. If you're
sure nobody else is going to grab them, it is usually best to wait.


but if you wait too long you can find parasites in them.
--

Knowledge is knowing a tomato is a fruit;
Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad

Ian Cundell 22-02-2004 12:32 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
In article ], Chris ]
wrote:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?


Because they are Satan's fungus and only devil worshippers are out and
about at that hour.

Stomach heaves at memory of school cheese and mushroom flan

Next week: Marmite - spawn of Beelzebub or Saddam's WMD?

--
"Noah's Ark is a problem...We'll have to call
it early quantum state phenomenon--
Only way to fit five-thousand
species of mammal on the same boat"

Alan Holmes 22-02-2004 02:58 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Franz Heymann" wrote in message
...

"Janet Bennett" wrote in message
...
Daft Answer I know, but probably people collected them before the cows

were
led back into the fields - probably cows like them for breakfast too!


Even dafter answer: Because if you don't collect them early, there won't

be
any left by the time you get there, since they will have been collected by
those who did collect them early.


So that's why I can never find any, but I'm too lazy to get up early anyway.

Alan
--
Reply to alan(at)windsor-berks(dot)freeserve(dot)co(dot)uk




Janet Baraclough .. 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off, the gills are very dark, the texture is a bit rubbery and
the flavour isn't as good.

Janet

Janet Baraclough .. 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off, the gills are very dark, the texture is a bit rubbery and
the flavour isn't as good.

Janet

[email protected] 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Insomniacs who like mushrooms.

Chuckie

[email protected] 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Insomniacs who like mushrooms.

Chuckie

Mary Fisher 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Baraclough .." wrote in
message ...
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off,


I don't.

the gills are very dark,


That's true but that's not important.

the texture is a bit rubbery


I disagree.

and
the flavour isn't as good.


I think the flavour is far better. There IS a flavour in older mushrooms and
very little in new ones.

Mary

Janet




Mary Fisher 22-02-2004 06:44 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Baraclough .." wrote in
message ...
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off,


I don't.

the gills are very dark,


That's true but that's not important.

the texture is a bit rubbery


I disagree.

and
the flavour isn't as good.


I think the flavour is far better. There IS a flavour in older mushrooms and
very little in new ones.

Mary

Janet




Janet Baraclough .. 22-02-2004 06:45 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off, the gills are very dark, the texture is a bit rubbery and
the flavour isn't as good.

Janet

[email protected] 22-02-2004 06:45 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Insomniacs who like mushrooms.

Chuckie

Mary Fisher 22-02-2004 06:45 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Baraclough .." wrote in
message ...
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off,


I don't.

the gills are very dark,


That's true but that's not important.

the texture is a bit rubbery


I disagree.

and
the flavour isn't as good.


I think the flavour is far better. There IS a flavour in older mushrooms and
very little in new ones.

Mary

Janet




Andy Hunt 22-02-2004 06:45 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
Whenever I've gone mushroom picking it's always been at dawn or dusk. Their
little white caps jump out at you in the twilight, and they are much easier
to see against the grass than during the day.

Andrew



"Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris




Franz Heymann 22-02-2004 11:30 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Baraclough .." wrote in
message ...
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.


The occurrences both before and after your semicolon are highly desirable.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off,


Why?

the gills are very dark,


Yes. What's wrong with that?

the texture is a bit rubbery


No.

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.

Franz





Franz Heymann 22-02-2004 11:38 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 

"Janet Baraclough .." wrote in
message ...
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage. They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho). The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.


The occurrences both before and after your semicolon are highly desirable.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off,


Why?

the gills are very dark,


Yes. What's wrong with that?

the texture is a bit rubbery


No.

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.

Franz





Jaques d'Alltrades 23-02-2004 03:40 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from (Larry Stoter) contains these words:

Generally though, mushrooms first emerge overnight and, as has been
mentioned, if you aren't first, you won't get any. Although, several
varieties - parasol, cep - can take several days to mature. If you're
sure nobody else is going to grab them, it is usually best to wait.


Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.

What is fairly rapid is the opening of the cap, especially as a result
of a warm night followed by a heavy dew, allowing the fungus to absorb
and use water quickly.

Then you find a wide cap because it's visible from a distance, and
discover lots of smaller ones nearby. But overnight it isn't.

--
Rusty
Open the creaking gate to make a horrid.squeak, then lower the foobar.
http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/hi-fi/

Jaques d'Alltrades 23-02-2004 03:40 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from (Larry Stoter) contains these words:

Generally though, mushrooms first emerge overnight and, as has been
mentioned, if you aren't first, you won't get any. Although, several
varieties - parasol, cep - can take several days to mature. If you're
sure nobody else is going to grab them, it is usually best to wait.


Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.

What is fairly rapid is the opening of the cap, especially as a result
of a warm night followed by a heavy dew, allowing the fungus to absorb
and use water quickly.

Then you find a wide cap because it's visible from a distance, and
discover lots of smaller ones nearby. But overnight it isn't.

--
Rusty
Open the creaking gate to make a horrid.squeak, then lower the foobar.
http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/hi-fi/

Jaques d'Alltrades 23-02-2004 04:02 AM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Janet Baraclough .. contains
these words:
The message ]
from Chris ] contains these words:


Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?


Mushrooms grow fast; they come up overnight and in the morning are at
the unopened button stage.


They take weeks to reach that stage.

They are clean, white, fresh, need no
peeling, and taste and cook better (imho).


No mushroom needs peeling - most of the flavour is in and just beneath
the top of the cap. And BTW, the flavours in fungi are mainly
oil-soluble, largely released by cooking with some fat or oil.

The older, open ones tend to
shrink and bleed juice more in the frying pan; or if you're making soup,
they make it unattractively dark.


The unattractiveness is a matter of opinion.

If you pick the very big open ones, the top has a skin that needs to be
peeled off, the gills are very dark, the texture is a bit rubbery and
the flavour isn't as good.


I would dispute all of these statements apart from the colour of the
gills. IMO the flavour is far and away better than the immature
specimens.

--
Rusty
Open the creaking gate to make a horrid.squeak, then lower the foobar.
http://www.users.zetnet.co.uk/hi-fi/

Paul Simonite 23-02-2004 03:49 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.



There is a patch of field mushrooms at my workplace. Each year I pick
them and each year I have to balance size against probability of maggot
infestation. You see, as Jacko Alltrades says, they take some days from
first appearing as dots to maturing into huge caps, meanwhile the flies
are busily laying their eggs all over them. The trick is to allow the
'shrooms to expand sufficiently to gain flavour (little flavour in
peedie ones) but not allow time for the fly eggs to develop into
burrowing maggots.

I suggest that the early morning picking idea is to take them when very
young before flies have a chance to damage them. Alas, if one does that
one inevitably sacrifices flavour and weight.

--
Cheers,
Compo

How do you know when your bagpipes need tuning?

Tim Challenger 23-02-2004 03:50 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 23:05:30 +0000 (UTC), Franz Heymann wrote:

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.


Yup. Absolutely.
--
Tim.

If the human brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we would
be so simple that we couldn't.

Paul Simonite 23-02-2004 08:09 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.



There is a patch of field mushrooms at my workplace. Each year I pick
them and each year I have to balance size against probability of maggot
infestation. You see, as Jacko Alltrades says, they take some days from
first appearing as dots to maturing into huge caps, meanwhile the flies
are busily laying their eggs all over them. The trick is to allow the
'shrooms to expand sufficiently to gain flavour (little flavour in
peedie ones) but not allow time for the fly eggs to develop into
burrowing maggots.

I suggest that the early morning picking idea is to take them when very
young before flies have a chance to damage them. Alas, if one does that
one inevitably sacrifices flavour and weight.

--
Cheers,
Compo

How do you know when your bagpipes need tuning?

Paul Simonite 23-02-2004 08:09 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.



There is a patch of field mushrooms at my workplace. Each year I pick
them and each year I have to balance size against probability of maggot
infestation. You see, as Jacko Alltrades says, they take some days from
first appearing as dots to maturing into huge caps, meanwhile the flies
are busily laying their eggs all over them. The trick is to allow the
'shrooms to expand sufficiently to gain flavour (little flavour in
peedie ones) but not allow time for the fly eggs to develop into
burrowing maggots.

I suggest that the early morning picking idea is to take them when very
young before flies have a chance to damage them. Alas, if one does that
one inevitably sacrifices flavour and weight.

--
Cheers,
Compo

How do you know when your bagpipes need tuning?

Paul Simonite 23-02-2004 08:34 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.



There is a patch of field mushrooms at my workplace. Each year I pick
them and each year I have to balance size against probability of maggot
infestation. You see, as Jacko Alltrades says, they take some days from
first appearing as dots to maturing into huge caps, meanwhile the flies
are busily laying their eggs all over them. The trick is to allow the
'shrooms to expand sufficiently to gain flavour (little flavour in
peedie ones) but not allow time for the fly eggs to develop into
burrowing maggots.

I suggest that the early morning picking idea is to take them when very
young before flies have a chance to damage them. Alas, if one does that
one inevitably sacrifices flavour and weight.

--
Cheers,
Compo

How do you know when your bagpipes need tuning?

Paul Simonite 23-02-2004 08:35 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
The message
from Jaques d'Alltrades contains
these words:

Old wives' tale. All mushrooms emerge over a period and can take many
days to get to a noticeable size.



There is a patch of field mushrooms at my workplace. Each year I pick
them and each year I have to balance size against probability of maggot
infestation. You see, as Jacko Alltrades says, they take some days from
first appearing as dots to maturing into huge caps, meanwhile the flies
are busily laying their eggs all over them. The trick is to allow the
'shrooms to expand sufficiently to gain flavour (little flavour in
peedie ones) but not allow time for the fly eggs to develop into
burrowing maggots.

I suggest that the early morning picking idea is to take them when very
young before flies have a chance to damage them. Alas, if one does that
one inevitably sacrifices flavour and weight.

--
Cheers,
Compo

How do you know when your bagpipes need tuning?

Tim Challenger 23-02-2004 08:36 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 23:05:30 +0000 (UTC), Franz Heymann wrote:

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.


Yup. Absolutely.
--
Tim.

If the human brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we would
be so simple that we couldn't.

Tim Challenger 23-02-2004 08:38 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 23:05:30 +0000 (UTC), Franz Heymann wrote:

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.


Yup. Absolutely.
--
Tim.

If the human brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we would
be so simple that we couldn't.

Tim Challenger 23-02-2004 08:38 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 23:05:30 +0000 (UTC), Franz Heymann wrote:

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.


Yup. Absolutely.
--
Tim.

If the human brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we would
be so simple that we couldn't.

Tim Challenger 23-02-2004 09:04 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
On Sun, 22 Feb 2004 23:05:30 +0000 (UTC), Franz Heymann wrote:

and the flavour isn't as good.


You and I are clearly familiar with very different kinds of mushroom. To
me, the small, unopened button mushrooms have no flavour worth talking
about, and large, open field mushrooms or boletus make heavenly slobbery
omelettes.


Yup. Absolutely.
--
Tim.

If the human brain were simple enough that we could understand it, we would
be so simple that we couldn't.

D Russell 24-02-2004 11:38 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
"Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


For breakfast !
D



D Russell 24-02-2004 11:41 PM

Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
 
"Chris" ] wrote in message
]...
Why do people collect mushrooms early in the morning?
--
Chris


For breakfast !
D




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
GardenBanter