Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Red Maple / Silver Maple What's the Difference?
Late last summer I purchased a small 7-foot tall maple tree that was
tagged as a red maple. When winter came what little leaves it had on it (the leaves got thrashed around at the nusery) simply fell off. No color change. This spring new leaves budded out, but they were just green. There was no red tipped branches or red buds. Right now the leaves are plain green on top, but the underside of the leaf isn't silvery like I think a silver maple leaf should look like. So here are my questions. How or when can I tell if this small maple is a red maple? Do I just wait until this fall to see if the leaves turn red? Patrick |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
wrote:
Late last summer I purchased a small 7-foot tall maple tree that was tagged as a red maple. When winter came what little leaves it had on it (the leaves got thrashed around at the nusery) simply fell off. No color change. This spring new leaves budded out, but they were just green. There was no red tipped branches or red buds. Right now the leaves are plain green on top, but the underside of the leaf isn't silvery like I think a silver maple leaf should look like. So here are my questions. How or when can I tell if this small maple is a red maple? Do I just wait until this fall to see if the leaves turn red? 7 feet tall is not a small tree to purchase. Call the nursery now. Dick |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
You can tell the difference by the color of the underside of the
leaves. If they are not silvery, then it is a red maple. You can also tell by the depth of the sinuses on the leaves- silver maple usually has much deeper sinuses than red maple. There are also several hybrids between the 2 trees (acer x freemanii) that have intermediate characteristics of both parents. The culitvars mentioned by david are actually the A. x freemanii species and not A. rubrum. Post a picture of the buds. Toad |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
" wrote in
oups.com: You can tell the difference by the color of the underside of the leaves. If they are not silvery, then it is a red maple. You can also tell by the depth of the sinuses on the leaves- silver maple usually has much deeper sinuses than red maple. There are also several hybrids between the 2 trees (acer x freemanii) that have intermediate characteristics of both parents. The culitvars mentioned by david are actually the A. x freemanii species and not A. rubrum. Post a picture of the buds. Toad 'Autumn Blaze'-- A. X FREEMANII 'Autumn Flame'-- A. RUBRUM 'Fairview Flame'-- A. RUBRUM 'October Glory'-- A. RUBRUM. -- David J. Bockman, Fairfax, VA (USDA Hardiness Zone 7) email: http://beyondgardening.com/Albums |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
David Bockman wrote:
" wrote in oups.com: You can tell the difference by the color of the underside of the leaves. If they are not silvery, then it is a red maple. You can also tell by the depth of the sinuses on the leaves- silver maple usually has much deeper sinuses than red maple. There are also several hybrids between the 2 trees (acer x freemanii) that have intermediate characteristics of both parents. The culitvars mentioned by david are actually the A. x freemanii species and not A. rubrum. Post a picture of the buds. Toad 'Autumn Blaze'-- A. X FREEMANII 'Autumn Flame'-- A. RUBRUM 'Fairview Flame'-- A. RUBRUM 'October Glory'-- A. RUBRUM. Many growers offer Red Maples that are actually part silver, for faster growth (faster growth = faster to market = more profit). These can be called "red" or something else. "Autumn Blaze" is a patented version of this hybrid. There's nothing wrong with that if the seller is honest about what they are doing. Some gardeners snub the silver maples, but silvers actually make pretty decent instant, non-permanent trees. I planted several silver and part-silver maples this year amongst some oaks. In ten or twenty years I'll thin out the maples and leave the oaks. If you live in an area with hurricaines or icy winters though, stay away from the silvers - they're too weak for those climates. The leaf on the Canadian flag is a red maple. If your maple has leaves with much deeper indentations then it is probably at least part silver, although maple leaf shapes do vary in nature from one population to another. Reds can have leaves that are grey or silver underneath like silvers. Make sure you don't have a Norway maple. These trees interbreed with local species and ruin them. Norways are currently a major problem in the sugar maple forests of Vermont. Recently I noticed at a local Kmart about thirty mis-labelled trees. The pots said everything from sycamore to buckey, but every one was some sort of maple. These stores don't always buy from the most reliable sources. I bought a tulip poplar from another Kmart this year that turned out to be a European sycamore. Guess I got what I paid for.... |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
red, red, red rose | Gardening | |||
black spots on silver maple leaves | Gardening | |||
Is this a Red or Silver Maple? | Gardening | |||
Silver Leaf Maple | Gardening | |||
Silver maple and wood boring ants | Gardening |