Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Tom,
She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. Kay Tom L. La Bron wrote: Kay, I am a breeder and I have snails in my ponds and my aquariums. She will never respond to me, because I prove her wrong off and on through the years and this has been going on in exchanges for years, so I have been on her kill list for years, but go ahead and ask which breeders and which writers of books. I have almost every book every written about Goldfish and snails are always listed as companions to Goldfish. Ingrid says stuff and never backs it up, but beings she says it it must be true, or so she believes. Tom L.L. ------------------------------------------------------- Kay wrote: wrote: Most people have no idea why their fish die. And frankly, it isnt my opinion that snails are not a good "companion" animal for pond fish. It is the opinion of the experts that breed fish, the experts that write the text books. I did start out my graduate studies in parasitology, so I have enough information to be very impressed with how nasty parasites are that spread thru intermediate hosts. consider that the dermal variety of schistosomiasis AKA swimmers itch is spread by snails... and the Pond Lady was getting horrendous itching and sores on arms and legs from her ponds. as for people buying snails to put in their pond... whatever winds your motor applies. Ingrid Kay wrote: I wanted to see how many people had illiness to their fish from snails because I disagree with Ingrid on the instances. I know there a black spot disease that come from infected snails, but I think that its not common at all, if not rare, with snails that hitch a ride on a plant bought from a petstore. Since lots of people if not all have goldfish, koi I wanted to see if anyone had fish sick from snails and if so what did they do and what illiness. Basically like a poll of fish keepers with pond and aquariums.Kay I think lots of animals can carry just about anything that a snail can. And being a breeder for money it would make sense to keep to a single specie enviorment, but I refuse to believe a snail on the average can kill a fish by hitching a ride on a plant from a LFS. Kay |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
snails
"Kay" wrote in message news:y85rc.85662$iF6.7299279@attbi_s02... Tom, She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. snip Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
snails
http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca
it is an old treatment that fell out of usage until a fish product company brought it back and started selling it again. It is also being touted by homeopathic concerns for various treatments. Ingrid "BenignVanilla" wrote: Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ List Manager: Puregold Goldfish List http://puregold.aquaria.net/ www.drsolo.com Solve the problem, dont waste energy finding who's to blame ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Unfortunately, I receive no money, gifts, discounts or other compensation for all the damn work I do, nor for any of the endorsements or recommendations I make. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
snails
BenignVanilla wrote:
"Kay" wrote in message news:y85rc.85662$iF6.7299279@attbi_s02... Tom, She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. snip Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca Kay |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Kay wrote:
Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca I, on the other hand, am not a big fan of Melafix. For one, I'm horridly allergic to it. For another, it appeared to aggrevate a case of nitrite poisoning that was occuring simulataneously with a case of fin rot on some of my newly acquired fish. It also seems a little too snail-oil like for my likings. I've seen no real scientific studies to back up the plethora of disorders it claims to treat. The only close to scientific study I've seen came to the conclusion that it really is only good as a prophalactic treatment with injured fish to prevent secondary infections and promote healing. http://www.koivet.com/html/articles/...article_id=104 |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Kay and BV,
If you take the time to read all that she has on her site what she uses as examples like the people allowing their baby to consume pure tea tree essential oil. (Melafix is only 1% tea tree oil) Nothing in the adverse effects area deals with fish; just Humans, dogs, cats and birds. The one that is really interesting is the bird lady who figured that if a little worked a lot would work better and killed her bird. Excuse me, who's fault was that. I.E., Golly gee, if 250 mg of antiboitic is working pretty good then 2000mg should work even better. Then there people like Cichlodot that is allergic to it, but you find that every where. Cottonpick if you give a teaspoon of salt to a young baby it will kill it, but do we stop using salt. Give me a break. Just some more of Ingrid's misuse of information trying to make a point that isn't valid just her opinion. Personally I think that it is great stuff and if it will work on Discus fry, it has got to be good and mild, because there is hardly any med you can use on Discus fry if they get sick, virtually everything kills them. I use it when an if it is needed as a first line of defense should something show up on my fish, and I certainly use it on new fish when they go into quarantine as one of the main meds that I use first on quarantined fish for 14 days when the fish come into my possession and go under quarantine whether they show any bad signs or not. It is good stuff. I use it in my soaps also. Tom L.L. ----------------------------------------------------- Kay wrote: BenignVanilla wrote: "Kay" wrote in message news:y85rc.85662$iF6.7299279@attbi_s02... Tom, She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. snip Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca Kay |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Tom L. La Bron wrote:
Just some more of Ingrid's misuse of information trying to make a point that isn't valid just her opinion. Personally I think that it is great stuff and if it will work on Discus fry, it has got to be good and mild, because there is hardly any med you can use on Discus fry if they get sick, virtually everything kills them. I use it when an if it is needed as a first line of defense should something show up on my fish, and I certainly use it on new fish when they go into quarantine as one of the main meds that I use first on quarantined fish for 14 days when the fish come into my possession and go under quarantine whether they show any bad signs or not. Perhaps I am old-fashioned, but I prefer to use medications for their proven purposes and not as a cure-all snake oil for things which they are not intended. Unfortunately, many aquarists seem to be treating Melafix as some panacea for all that ails fish, which just is not true. Melafix only claims to promote healing of skin and fins. If you read carefully, you will note that even though they list off a variety of illnesses, they do not claim to cure those illnesses, only promote healing of damaged tissue. Thus, it really isn't useful as a prophalactic unless the new fish have experienced some sort of wounds or fin damage. Adding it to a tank with non-injured fish will probably do no harm, but isn't going to magically help with any mystery diseases either. This tendancy of people to use Melafix as a panacea combined with my allergies to it makes me rather critical of its overuse. Really, if you want the best "magical" cure for most that ails fish, nothing beats keeping the water clean with regular maintenance. I've had several cases of beat up fish or fin nipping since I discovered my allergy to Melafix. Some of these were rather severe with my cichlids (the fish hanging listless at the corner of the tank). All of them recovered when moved to a quiet tank with good water quality. No Melafix needed really. As for quarantine, observation is best IMO, perhaps combined with feeding of medicated food against internal parasites since those can take a while to develop external symptoms. My approach to sick fish is pretty much similar to beat up fish. Move them to a quiet, clean hospital tank. Observe for symptoms and then apply the most appropriate medication given the symptoms. I also tend to prefer the medicated food approach when that is indicated, particularly for suspected internal infections. Most recently this was a fish that bloated up overnight. The symptoms did not seem consistent with either bacterial or parasitic infections known to cause bloat, so I just treated with epsom salts for constipation. Sure enough, about 5 days later he passed what appeared to be cat hair (which considering I have water loving cats is not unlikely). Within a day, all swelling was gone and he was back to his previously fiesty self. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Cichlidiot,
I can not agree with you more about using a med for what is intended. I usually get fish from other breeders I usually just observe them through the quarantine to see if something is going to show up. When I do get fish from a LFS I don't take any chances, plus, since when I do get them from the LFS I usually get them the day they arrive and after being intransit in bags I get fish that may look a little tattered, so when I bring them home I use the Melafix as part of the quarantine procedure. During the month long quarantine of new fish, on the 10th day of the 14 day Melafix treatment I start feeding a medicated food for 14 days. There is a couple of days at the beginning of quarantine where I observe the fish before adding the Melafix. As far as a Panacea goes that is other peoples problems, I read the label and use it accordingly. I have never used it that way or suggested its use other than what the label instructions indicate. What other aquarist do is not the fault of the med, how they use it outside of it indicated realm is their choice. I have always been an advocate of clean water and proper water maintenance. That has been my mantra for decades; the way to healthy fish is three steps, 1. Clean water, 2. Clear Water, and last but not least 3. Clean water. I learned a long time ago if you take care of your water your fish will be health. I don't believe in dumping a lot of stuff in to the water, I never have and never will. Your approach to your fish seems similar to mine except that you can't use Melafix where appropriate. Are you affected by contact only or does the aroma cause problems also? Have a great day. Tom L.L. -------------------------------------------------------- Cichlidiot wrote: Perhaps I am old-fashioned, but I prefer to use medications for their proven purposes and not as a cure-all snake oil for things which they are not intended. Unfortunately, many aquarists seem to be treating Melafix as some panacea for all that ails fish, which just is not true. Melafix only claims to promote healing of skin and fins. If you read carefully, you will note that even though they list off a variety of illnesses, they do not claim to cure those illnesses, only promote healing of damaged tissue. Thus, it really isn't useful as a prophalactic unless the new fish have experienced some sort of wounds or fin damage. Adding it to a tank with non-injured fish will probably do no harm, but isn't going to magically help with any mystery diseases either. This tendancy of people to use Melafix as a panacea combined with my allergies to it makes me rather critical of its overuse. Really, if you want the best "magical" cure for most that ails fish, nothing beats keeping the water clean with regular maintenance. I've had several cases of beat up fish or fin nipping since I discovered my allergy to Melafix. Some of these were rather severe with my cichlids (the fish hanging listless at the corner of the tank). All of them recovered when moved to a quiet tank with good water quality. No Melafix needed really. As for quarantine, observation is best IMO, perhaps combined with feeding of medicated food against internal parasites since those can take a while to develop external symptoms. My approach to sick fish is pretty much similar to beat up fish. Move them to a quiet, clean hospital tank. Observe for symptoms and then apply the most appropriate medication given the symptoms. I also tend to prefer the medicated food approach when that is indicated, particularly for suspected internal infections. Most recently this was a fish that bloated up overnight. The symptoms did not seem consistent with either bacterial or parasitic infections known to cause bloat, so I just treated with epsom salts for constipation. Sure enough, about 5 days later he passed what appeared to be cat hair (which considering I have water loving cats is not unlikely). Within a day, all swelling was gone and he was back to his previously fiesty self. |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Cichlidiot wrote:
Kay wrote: Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca I, on the other hand, am not a big fan of Melafix. For one, I'm horridly allergic to it. For another, it appeared to aggrevate a case of nitrite poisoning that was occuring simulataneously with a case of fin rot on some of my newly acquired fish. It also seems a little too snail-oil like for my likings. I've seen no real scientific studies to back up the plethora of disorders it claims to treat. The only close to scientific study I've seen came to the conclusion that it really is only good as a prophalactic treatment with injured fish to prevent secondary infections and promote healing. http://www.koivet.com/html/articles/...article_id=104 With my fish, I have never expierenced nitrite poinoning. I do use tea tree oil and my family for years personally. Of coarse if I was allergic then that would be another story. We respect it and use it carefully like medicine. Tea tree, Myrrth, Pepermint, Lavender and Sweet Majorim have replaced, bengay, headace meds, anti- bacterial creams anit-fungal medicines, Bone pain drugs, and nerve pain medicines In my family. I guess I;m lucky not to be allergic. Kay |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Tom,
I remember when I first found out about some of these oils. I was at a childs b-day party with a horrible headache. I asked my sister in law for something for it and she asked me to try lavender. I thought she was a loon and that the lavender would make it worse. It worked for me. After that I tried more. Came across tea tree about 10 years ago. again I guess its different if there is an allergy. Kay and BV, If you take the time to read all that she has on her site what she uses as examples like the people allowing their baby to consume pure tea tree essential oil. (Melafix is only 1% tea tree oil) Nothing in the adverse effects area deals with fish; just Humans, dogs, cats and birds. The one that is really interesting is the bird lady who figured that if a little worked a lot would work better and killed her bird. Excuse me, who's fault was that. I.E., Golly gee, if 250 mg of antiboitic is working pretty good then 2000mg should work even better. Then there people like Cichlodot that is allergic to it, but you find that every where. Cottonpick if you give a teaspoon of salt to a young baby it will kill it, but do we stop using salt. Give me a break. Just some more of Ingrid's misuse of information trying to make a point that isn't valid just her opinion. Personally I think that it is great stuff and if it will work on Discus fry, it has got to be good and mild, because there is hardly any med you can use on Discus fry if they get sick, virtually everything kills them. I use it when an if it is needed as a first line of defense should something show up on my fish, and I certainly use it on new fish when they go into quarantine as one of the main meds that I use first on quarantined fish for 14 days when the fish come into my possession and go under quarantine whether they show any bad signs or not. It is good stuff. I use it in my soaps also. Tom L.L. ----------------------------------------------------- Kay wrote: BenignVanilla wrote: "Kay" wrote in message news:y85rc.85662$iF6.7299279@attbi_s02... Tom, She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. snip Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca Kay |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Cichlidiot wrote:
Tom L. La Bron wrote: Just some more of Ingrid's misuse of information trying to make a point that isn't valid just her opinion. Personally I think that it is great stuff and if it will work on Discus fry, it has got to be good and mild, because there is hardly any med you can use on Discus fry if they get sick, virtually everything kills them. I use it when an if it is needed as a first line of defense should something show up on my fish, and I certainly use it on new fish when they go into quarantine as one of the main meds that I use first on quarantined fish for 14 days when the fish come into my possession and go under quarantine whether they show any bad signs or not. Perhaps I am old-fashioned, but I prefer to use medications for their proven purposes and not as a cure-all snake oil for things which they are not intended. Unfortunately, many aquarists seem to be treating Melafix as some panacea for all that ails fish, which just is not true. Melafix only claims to promote healing of skin and fins. If you read carefully, you will note that even though they list off a variety of illnesses, they do not claim to cure those illnesses, only promote healing of damaged tissue. Thus, it really isn't useful as a prophalactic unless the new fish have experienced some sort of wounds or fin damage. Adding it to a tank with non-injured fish will probably do no harm, but isn't going to magically help with any mystery diseases either. This tendancy of people to use Melafix as a panacea combined with my allergies to it makes me rather critical of its overuse. Really, if you want the best "magical" cure for most that ails fish, nothing beats keeping the water clean with regular maintenance. I've had several cases of beat up fish or fin nipping since I discovered my allergy to Melafix. Some of these were rather severe with my cichlids (the fish hanging listless at the corner of the tank). All of them recovered when moved to a quiet tank with good water quality. No Melafix needed really. As for quarantine, observation is best IMO, perhaps combined with feeding of medicated food against internal parasites since those can take a while to develop external symptoms. My approach to sick fish is pretty much similar to beat up fish. Move them to a quiet, clean hospital tank. Observe for symptoms and then apply the most appropriate medication given the symptoms. I also tend to prefer the medicated food approach when that is indicated, particularly for suspected internal infections. Most recently this was a fish that bloated up overnight. The symptoms did not seem consistent with either bacterial or parasitic infections known to cause bloat, so I just treated with epsom salts for constipation. Sure enough, about 5 days later he passed what appeared to be cat hair (which considering I have water loving cats is not unlikely). Within a day, all swelling was gone and he was back to his previously fiesty self. Speaking of medicated food. I live in chicago near midway airport and so far I have not seen this medcated food for sale in the LFS I have been in. Is there a reason why these medicated foods are not in alot of stores? I have checked chain and family owned shops where I live. So far I have never needed it but, I have read alot about it and wanted to see who had it and how much. People have told me to buy the meds and soak fish food in it, but what meds and how much is to general if I ever needed it. Kay |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Absolutely. Pristine water. I am trying to convince people that a "hospital" or
quarantine tank should be a minimum of a 40 gallon rubbermaid tub (or larger like 100 gallon stock tank for koi). And the best "meds" for abraded skin is a bit of salt. Just like we are told to gargle with salt water for canker sore or sore throat. Ingrid Cichlidiot wrote: Perhaps I am old-fashioned, but I prefer to use medications for their proven purposes and not as a cure-all snake oil for things which they are not intended. Really, if you want the best "magical" cure for most that ails fish, nothing beats keeping the water clean with regular maintenance. ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ List Manager: Puregold Goldfish List http://puregold.aquaria.net/ www.drsolo.com Solve the problem, dont waste energy finding who's to blame ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Unfortunately, I receive no money, gifts, discounts or other compensation for all the damn work I do, nor for any of the endorsements or recommendations I make. |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Kay,
There are always going to be people allergic to something. I am on several soap listservs and there is always someone who is allergic to something, but that doesn't make it bad for the rest of us. I'm sorry, but that it their problem to read the label and be careful. Most 100% essential oils can be dangerous if used improperly, Wintergreen being one of the worse of them all, which makes using Wintergreen fragrance oil a better choice. I have been using Tea Tree oil for my fish long before Melafix, so I know personally it works, but before Melafix I never suggested any one use it, because Tea Tree oil can be used improperly. What I find interesting is that it is referred to as snail-oil when there has been a lot of research done with it, just not in the states, because of its herbal connection. We here in the states are too hooked on scientific meds, which for most part come from natural sources to begin with, but that information is very seldom released. I make an eye-pillow with a combination of herbals and spices that works great for headaches and another one as a sleep aid. But are all labeled, that if you have any plant allergies you need to see the ingredient listing. Tom L.L. Kay wrote: Tom, I remember when I first found out about some of these oils. I was at a childs b-day party with a horrible headache. I asked my sister in law for something for it and she asked me to try lavender. I thought she was a loon and that the lavender would make it worse. It worked for me. After that I tried more. Came across tea tree about 10 years ago. again I guess its different if there is an allergy. Kay and BV, If you take the time to read all that she has on her site what she uses as examples like the people allowing their baby to consume pure tea tree essential oil. (Melafix is only 1% tea tree oil) Nothing in the adverse effects area deals with fish; just Humans, dogs, cats and birds. The one that is really interesting is the bird lady who figured that if a little worked a lot would work better and killed her bird. Excuse me, who's fault was that. I.E., Golly gee, if 250 mg of antiboitic is working pretty good then 2000mg should work even better. Then there people like Cichlodot that is allergic to it, but you find that every where. Cottonpick if you give a teaspoon of salt to a young baby it will kill it, but do we stop using salt. Give me a break. Just some more of Ingrid's misuse of information trying to make a point that isn't valid just her opinion. Personally I think that it is great stuff and if it will work on Discus fry, it has got to be good and mild, because there is hardly any med you can use on Discus fry if they get sick, virtually everything kills them. I use it when an if it is needed as a first line of defense should something show up on my fish, and I certainly use it on new fish when they go into quarantine as one of the main meds that I use first on quarantined fish for 14 days when the fish come into my possession and go under quarantine whether they show any bad signs or not. It is good stuff. I use it in my soaps also. Tom L.L. ----------------------------------------------------- Kay wrote: BenignVanilla wrote: "Kay" wrote in message news:y85rc.85662$iF6.7299279@attbi_s02... Tom, She says she has no time to do the compling of all the sources. I would be interested in a website that has actual discredit the artilces that have no basis. Like the tea tree oil statement. snip Ooh, ooh. What's the tea tree oil statement? I am a big TTO fan. BV. Here is the link. I think its totally false. I am a fan of melafix. http://puregold.aquaria.net/pg/care/...L,%20Melaleuca Kay |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
snails
Kay wrote:
Tom, I remember when I first found out about some of these oils. I was at a childs b-day party with a horrible headache. I asked my sister in law for something for it and she asked me to try lavender. I thought she was a loon and that the lavender would make it worse. It worked for me. After that I tried more. Came across tea tree about 10 years ago. again I guess its different if there is an allergy. Heh, I'm allergic to lavender as well, about the same symptoms as Melafix. Reddened skin with contact, sneezing my fool head off and burning, watery eyes like crazy. I can even tell when the LFS has used Melafix before the smell hits me as my eyes start watering and my nose stuffs up. The symptoms occur even when I am taking allergy medicines (which control my mite/insect allergy, otherwise I'd be sneezing constantly). I do have severe allergy problems though. You should see how my left arm looks right now from Monday's recycling project... little red welts all over from the bug exposure when I recycled 2 months worth of papers that had been stacked in a corner. And I even took precautions to take my meds a couple hours before and clean up right after to minimize allergen exposure, but once I get bit, I usually get welts. At least it wasn't fleas, then I'd have red scars for months. Problem is that most "standard" skin tests for allergies in the USA don't include very many ornamental plants unless they're a major wind-born pollen producer. Also, they don't test plant oils, at least not in the test I took. So people who might have these allergies could not just go to a doctor for a skin test to rule them out (the blood test requires recent exposure to the allergen to register the antibodies in the blood). I actually registered below threshold on many of the pollen tests, but get me around any strong perfumes, aroma therapy, essential oils, etc and I start stuffing up within minutes. So I think a good thing to ask people before advocating essential oil use is if they've had allergy problems with perfumes or aroma therapies, then warn them to proceed with caution if they have. The mints by the way are usually fine for me, it's just the teas and lavender I've had problems with, along with rose. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Snail, snails, snails | Gardening | |||
Snails good? or Snails bad? | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
Snails - Benifit or Pest?////Zebra Snails | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
Good snails/ Bad snails/ controll | Freshwater Aquaria Plants | |||
Good snails/ Bad snails/ controll | Freshwater Aquaria Plants |