Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Best way to treat a lawn that is shared with guinea pigs
Neil Jones wrote: Mike Lyle wrote: [...] As a sometimes enthusiastic revisionist about many things, I agree it's an interesting site; but it doesn't seem to quote very many papers, and it certainly doesn't deny the toxicity of these plants. There is an abvious logical flaw in what you are saying. Just because a website says something that a lot of other websites do not say does not mean it is wrong. It is the scientific facts that count. There actually isn't a lot of study that has been done so the fact that ony a few papers are quoted does nothing to undermine credibility, I detect no logical flaw in my comments. You will note that I do not challenge the three (I think) papers quoted on the site, which agree with my other reading or, in the case of seed distribution, my informal personal observation. My impression is that there's been a lot of study over the years. RAgwort poisoning is actually very rare, but certain people have made a big fuss and misused statistics in a very very unethical way to mislead people. We know it is very rare because internationally there are a set of scientific papers that say this. You find for example that someone has written a scientific paper in Holland because of a poisoning incident, caused incidentally by gross stupidity, and that it is interesting because a case hasn't been reported in years. The French looked into it and couldn't find a case! It's rare because farmers take the usual precautions. In fact, poisoning by plants in general is rare. That doesn't make it unreal. You don't want them in hay or silage. That is the only place they cause problems and then only if there is sufficient. That's broadly true, which is why I said what I said. There are recorded cases of poisoning by fresh material, though: for an extreme example, Forsyth in HMSO 161 reports personal observation of the whole course of an outbreak in a flock of 140 ewes in Iraq. [...] Small doses will cause ZERO damage because of a whole series of biochemical thresholds which have to be exceeded before any damage is done to the animal at all. The compounds in Ragwort are actually non-toxic and have to be converted before they can cause damage. But I understand that the hepatotoxic alkaloids in ragworts do act directly on the viscera. It's true that death results from the liver damage after the toxins themselves are no longer present in the affected animal, but this is neither here nor the the damage is done. [...] Of course people shouldn't panic about the ragworts; but they _are_ toxic, and they aren't endangered, so getting them out is generally a good idea, especially in fodder crops. Even if one has no susceptible stock, I think it's reasonable to be a good neighbour to others, [...] As an entomologist I know there is a basic rule. ALL plants contain toxins of one kind or another. Brassica poisonging and Onion poisoning are both well known in livestock. Brassicas contain allyl isothiocynate and the lethal dose of that in cattle is around 0.001% of body weight. Which is why farmers take precautions. I think the maximum ration of kale is about 15-20kg/day. The environmental effects of such a law could be disastrous. People removing bluebells and foxgloves because they believe it is demanded by law. Imagine having to destroy all those woods full of wild garlic. Oak trees are mildly poisonous too! We already have people believing that you have to control ragwort by law which is not the case. And, of course, to quote you above, "I shan't name them because I don;t want to start another bout of hysteria"... You'll forgive me, I hope; but it really does seem that when somebody comes along and broadly agrees with your substantive point, it just isn't good enough for you. You seem to want to be agreed with word for word on the details: I'm afraid I can't oblige. -- Mike. |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
Cheers, Dave. |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Lawns & guinea pigs | Lawns | |||
Grass lawn v guinea pigs...advice please | United Kingdom | |||
Vegetable garden for guinea pigs (and people too!) | Edible Gardening | |||
Furze pigs | United Kingdom |