Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
I have a large olive in a pot in my patio garden and it has grown very well,
however I notice in the last few days that ants are entering the pot from the bottom and taking soil out (only small amounts). Are they living in it? Will it hurt the plant? I have tried moving the olive but they seem to follow it around! Any advice? Mike |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
"Mike" wrote in message
... I have a large olive in a pot in my patio garden and it has grown very well, however I notice in the last few days that ants are entering the pot from the bottom and taking soil out (only small amounts). Are they living in it? Will it hurt the plant? I have tried moving the olive but they seem to follow it around! Any advice? Mike If the ants form a colony in the pot it certainly will be detrimental to the plant so I would deter them by standing the pot in water for a short while and this will cause the ants to disperse. Then place the pot in an ant free spot and hopefully all will be well. Regards, Emrys Davies. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
In article , "Emrys Davies" writes: | | If the ants form a colony in the pot it certainly will be detrimental to | the plant so I would deter them by standing the pot in water for a short | while and this will cause the ants to disperse. Then place the pot in | an ant free spot and hopefully all will be well. That is not true. Some plants dislike ants in their roots; others are unaffected, and may even appreciate it. Your solution is the correct one for the former case, of course. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Mike,
Just found this more sophisticated method of ant control. You may think that it has merit. http://www.pan-uk.org/pestnews/homepest/ants.htm Regards, Emrys Davies. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
g'day mike,
no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their symbiotic bugs in as well. the best way is to stand the pots in water up the the brim for around 24 hours to flood the nest, keep the water up to the brim but not over for that period. then have trays under the pot that will hold water and using those specila pot stands or pieces of tile etc.,. to use to hold the pot above that water level that will keep them out so long as none of the foliage touches anything that the ants can use to climb back into the pot. len On Thu, 24 May 2007 06:55:07 GMT, "Mike" wrote: snipped With peace and brightest of blessings, len & bev -- "Be Content With What You Have And May You Find Serenity and Tranquillity In A World That You May Not Understand." http://www.lensgarden.com.au/ |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
|
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
"len garden" wrote in message ... g'day mike, no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their symbiotic bugs in as well. the best way is to stand the pots in water up the the brim for around 24 hours to flood the nest, keep the water up to the brim but not over for that period. then have trays under the pot that will hold water and using those specila pot stands or pieces of tile etc.,. to use to hold the pot above that water level that will keep them out so long as none of the foliage touches anything that the ants can use to climb back into the pot. I've never had any real problems with ants in pots or any other part of the garden, they are a right pain when they get into the house though! |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Sacha wrote:
"len garden" wrote: no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their symbiotic bugs in as well. What symbiotic bugs would those be? [...] Sap suckers: ``Some ant species, such as the common Black garden ants (Lasius niger) found in the UK, farm aphids. They have aphid livestock which they transport between plants and protect from enemies in return for a sugary substance called honeydew, excreted from the aphids as they suck on plant sap.'' http://www.buglife.org.uk/discoverbu...ationships.htm -- __________ |im |yler http://timtyler.org/ Remove lock to reply. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
On 24/5/07 22:41, in article , "Alan
Holmes" wrote: "len garden" wrote in message ... g'day mike, no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their symbiotic bugs in as well. the best way is to stand the pots in water up the the brim for around 24 hours to flood the nest, keep the water up to the brim but not over for that period. then have trays under the pot that will hold water and using those specila pot stands or pieces of tile etc.,. to use to hold the pot above that water level that will keep them out so long as none of the foliage touches anything that the ants can use to climb back into the pot. I've never had any real problems with ants in pots or any other part of the garden, they are a right pain when they get into the house though! In what way, Alan? I lived in an old house that had them all over the place. The most fascinating thing I've ever watched was two 'tribes' fighting. Each tribe was the size of a large soup plate and they were in the middle of the dining room floor. But if I kept all food covered securely or sealed, they did us no harm. -- Sacha http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk (remove weeds from address) |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
In article , Tim Tyler writes: | Sacha wrote: | "len garden" wrote: | | no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their | symbiotic bugs in as well. | | What symbiotic bugs would those be? [...] | | Sap suckers: | | ``Some ant species, such as the common Black garden ants | (Lasius niger) found in the UK, farm aphids. They have | aphid livestock which they transport between plants and | protect from enemies in return for a sugary substance | called honeydew, excreted from the aphids as they suck | on plant sap.'' All of the references I have seen, and my observation over many years, indicate that is at best an urban myth. More bluntly, it is just plain wrong. I don't know whether there are any 'farming' ant species in the UK - most references are evasive on that - but Lasius niger is not one of them. It does do some desultory herding, but that is about all. I have seen one decent reference that indicates that it may assist aphids, but the research had a fair number of possible flaws, and it was done so long ago that I couldn't check with the author. It is vanishingly unlikely that Lasius niger will import aphids onto plants in posts that they are nesting in. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Tim Tyler wrote:
Sacha wrote: "len garden" wrote: no is the answer they can cause all sort of problems and bring their symbiotic bugs in as well. What symbiotic bugs would those be? [...] Sap suckers: ``Some ant species, such as the common Black garden ants (Lasius niger) found in the UK, farm aphids. They have aphid livestock which they transport between plants and protect from enemies in return for a sugary substance called honeydew, excreted from the aphids as they suck on plant sap.'' The aphids bite into the plant and lock on, there is then a continuous flow of honey dew from their rear end, the ant take advantage of this free food fountain! If the flow stops they tickle the ant's rear end to get it going pk |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Nick Maclaren wrote:
Tim Tyler writes: | Sap suckers: | | ``Some ant species, such as the common Black garden ants | (Lasius niger) found in the UK, farm aphids. They have | aphid livestock which they transport between plants and | protect from enemies in return for a sugary substance | called honeydew, excreted from the aphids as they suck | on plant sap.'' All of the references I have seen, and my observation over many years, indicate that is at best an urban myth. More bluntly, it is just plain wrong. I don't know whether there are any 'farming' ant species in the UK - most references are evasive on that - but Lasius niger is not one of them. It does do some desultory herding, but that is about all. I have seen one decent reference that indicates that it may assist aphids, but the research had a fair number of possible flaws, and it was done so long ago that I couldn't check with the author. The best first hand evidence I have of UK black ants doing more than exploit existing aphids is the earth castles they sometimes build to protect them from overheating: http://sprouting.org/temp/ants/ ....has photos. I have now seen these things built six inches high. When the growing point is too high off the ground, for a tower to reach, the ants can still carry moist earth up and stick it on around the target area. http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=15221511 ....has Lasius niger excluding predators from aphid colonies: ``Large predators were excluded by both ant species from the aphid colonies, while they were abundant in ant-excluded colonies.'' http://jeb.biologists.org/cgi/content/abstract/35/4/703 ....has Lasius niger sucking twice as much juice out of beans when attended by ants. ....and this looks pretty conclusive to me: http://www.brown.edu/Departments/EEB...00_ecology.pdf ``The presence of workers of the ant Lasius niger had a strong positive effect on the fitness of individuals of the aphid Metopeurum fuscoviride. Ant-tended individuals lived longer, matured earlier, had a higher rate of re-production, and a higher expected number of offspring than aphids not tended by ants. An aphid’s longevity was significantly correlated with the daily mean number of workers tending it.'' -- __________ |im |yler http://timtyler.org/ Remove lock to reply. |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
In article , Tim Tyler writes: | | | Sap suckers: | | | | ``Some ant species, such as the common Black garden ants | | (Lasius niger) found in the UK, farm aphids. They have | | aphid livestock which they transport between plants and | | protect from enemies in return for a sugary substance | | called honeydew, excreted from the aphids as they suck | | on plant sap.'' | | All of the references I have seen, and my observation over many | years, indicate that is at best an urban myth. More bluntly, it | is just plain wrong. I don't know whether there are any 'farming' | ant species in the UK - most references are evasive on that - but | Lasius niger is not one of them. | | It does do some desultory herding, but that is about all. I have | seen one decent reference that indicates that it may assist aphids, | but the research had a fair number of possible flaws, and it was | done so long ago that I couldn't check with the author. Thanks for the references. I have looked for evidence in many parts of the country, and never seen it, so my estimate is that it can't be a universal practice. Black bean aphids and L. niger are universal in the UK :-) But, yes, I agree that the last paper is strong evidence for herding. What NONE of those are is evidence for farming, and one of the papers you quote says that they saw none, either. | The best first hand evidence I have of UK black | ants doing more than exploit existing aphids is | the earth castles they sometimes build to protect | them from overheating: They told you why they did it? Please tell more :-) Seriously, I have occasionally seen this, but have never seen any justification for the claimed reason they do it. That may be right, but its rareness makes me think that it isn't. | http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=15221511 | | ...has Lasius niger excluding predators from aphid | colonies: | | ``Large predators were excluded by both ant species from the | aphid colonies, while they were abundant in ant-excluded colonies.'' Let's quote a bit mo L. niger workers often carried living aphids away from the attended colonies, whereas P. pungens removed no aphids and disregarded parasitized aphids, thereby incidentally protecting the parasitized aphids from predators. Thus, P. pungens attending T. citricidus largely enhances parasitism by L. japonicus and its larval survival, compared with when ants are absent, whereas L. niger exerts no remarkable impact. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Nick Maclaren wrote:
Thanks for the references. I have looked for evidence in many parts of the country, and never seen it, so my estimate is that it can't be a universal practice. Black bean aphids and L. niger are universal in the UK :-) But, yes, I agree that the last paper is strong evidence for herding. What NONE of those are is evidence for farming, and one of the papers you quote says that they saw none, either. Ants elimitate aphid predators and reduce aphid infections. ``In turn, ants often act as guards and decrease the impact of predators and parasitoids on the fitness of their hosts (El-Ziady and Kennedy 1956, Banks 1962, Way 1963, Banks and Macaulay 1967, Addicott 1979, Pierce and Mead 1981, Buckley 1987a, b, Vo¨ lkl 1992).'' - http://www.brown.edu/Departments/EEB...00_ecology.pdf Their effect on aphid fitness is dramatic and positive: ``Ant-tended individuals of M. fuscoviride lived on average 78% longer, needed 10% less time to mature, gave birth to offspring at a rate that was 88% higher, and had an expected number of offspring that was more than five times higher than that of individuals not tended by ants.'' - http://www.brown.edu/Departments/EEB...00_ecology.pdf ....and they cause the aphids to suck more sap out of plants: ``It must be concluded that the ant-attended aphids produced the 'extra' radioactivity in the honeydew by increasing the uptake of radioactive sap from the plants. It follows, therefore, as Herzig supposed, that the ants directly stimulated both the excretion and feeding rates of the aphids.'' - http://jeb.biologists.org/cgi/reprint/35/4/703.pdf Ants consume aphid milk, and consume aphid flesh. They tend many species of subterranean aphids in their nests: ``Subterranean aphids seem more restricted in the species of their mutualist, for example the aphid Aphis maidiradicis was thought to have an intimate association with Lasius niger americana (Forbes 1894). However A. maidiridicis has since been seen to associate with at least five other ant species from two genera (Way 1963) and at least 17 species of aphid have been found in the nests of L. niger (Schouteden 1902).'' - http://www.msu.edu/~shingle9/NewFile...teractions.pdf What other properties do you think would be needed for these ants to qualify as 'farmers' rather than 'herders'? -- __________ |im |yler http://timtyler.org/ Remove lock to reply. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Ants in planted pots ok?
Tim Tyler wrote:
Nick Maclaren wrote: I don't know whether there are any 'farming' ant species in the UK - most references are evasive on that - but Lasius niger is not one of them. http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=15221511 ...has Lasius niger excluding predators from aphid colonies: ``Large predators were excluded by both ant species from the aphid colonies, while they were abundant in ant-excluded colonies.'' and better still, ``L. niger workers often carried living aphids away from the attended colonies, whereas P pungens removed no aphids...'' I didn't know they did that, but surely that counts as farming? Peter |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
ants,ants, and more ants, AAAARRRRRRGGGG | Gardening | |||
Ants in pots | United Kingdom | |||
ants v Amdro -- ants winning | Texas | |||
Ants, ants and more ants.... | Australia | |||
Ants, ants and more ants.... | Australia |