Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
Hello
with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant material. What opinions if any do you folks have. TIA ..........................leslie -- Posted via NewsDemon.com - Premium Uncensored Newsgroup Service -------http://www.NewsDemon.com------ Unlimited Access, Anonymous Accounts, Uncensored Broadband Access |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
Leslie wrote with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant material. What opinions if any do you folks have. http://www.rhs.org.uk/Advice/profile...ato_blight.asp -- Regards Bob Hobden |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
In article , "Bob Hobden" writes: | Leslie wrote | with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. | | I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other | advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant | material. | | What opinions if any do you folks have. | | http://www.rhs.org.uk/Advice/profile...ato_blight.asp That still promotes the old wife's tale that it isn't safe to compost blighted plants - that is quite simply wrong. Blight in the UK CURRENTLY overwinters only on living material (typically potato tubers, and possibly native Solanum species). The reason is that spores produced by a single strain do not overwinter, and it needs a sort of sexual stage to produce ones that do. Currently, this has not been demonstrated to occur in the UK. In this, Wikipedia is more reliable than the RHS - though I am basing my statement on academic papers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytophthora_infestans Yes, it's safe to compost blighted plant material, provided that you ensure that any potato tubers in it do not survive composting and, to a lesser extent, the blight spores are not spread from the material on the compost heap. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
"Nick Maclaren" wrote in message ... In article , "Bob Hobden" writes: | Leslie wrote | with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. | | I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other | advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant | material. | | What opinions if any do you folks have. | | http://www.rhs.org.uk/Advice/profile...ato_blight.asp That still promotes the old wife's tale that it isn't safe to compost blighted plants - that is quite simply wrong. Blight in the UK CURRENTLY overwinters only on living material (typically potato tubers, and possibly native Solanum species). The reason is that spores produced by a single strain do not overwinter, and it needs a sort of sexual stage to produce ones that do. Currently, this has not been demonstrated to occur in the UK. In this, Wikipedia is more reliable than the RHS - though I am basing my statement on academic papers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytophthora_infestans Yes, it's safe to compost blighted plant material, provided that you ensure that any potato tubers in it do not survive composting and, to a lesser extent, the blight spores are not spread from the material on the compost heap. Regards, Nick Maclaren. That's twice we agree today! |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
"Nick Maclaren" wrote "Bob Hobden" writes: | Leslie wrote | with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. | | I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other | advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant | material. | | What opinions if any do you folks have. | | http://www.rhs.org.uk/Advice/profile...ato_blight.asp That still promotes the old wife's tale that it isn't safe to compost blighted plants - that is quite simply wrong. Blight in the UK CURRENTLY overwinters only on living material (typically potato tubers, and possibly native Solanum species). The reason is that spores produced by a single strain do not overwinter, and it needs a sort of sexual stage to produce ones that do. Currently, this has not been demonstrated to occur in the UK. In this, Wikipedia is more reliable than the RHS - though I am basing my statement on academic papers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytophthora_infestans Yes, it's safe to compost blighted plant material, provided that you ensure that any potato tubers in it do not survive composting and, to a lesser extent, the blight spores are not spread from the material on the compost heap. I would not take the chance, it's simply not worth the risk composting any diseased plant material. -- Regards Bob Hobden |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
In article , "Bob Hobden" writes: | | Yes, it's safe to compost blighted plant material, provided that | you ensure that any potato tubers in it do not survive composting | and, to a lesser extent, the blight spores are not spread from the | material on the compost heap. | | I would not take the chance, it's simply not worth the risk composting any | diseased plant material. As a statistician, that sort of thing makes me despair! You bend over backwards to minimise a negligible risk, but I will bet a guinea to a farthing that you completely ignore much more serious ones. For example, even just with composting, you should never compost UNCOOKED plant material that has come from outside and might have even been in contact with plant material. Yes, that does mean cooking any paper bags or cardboard that you have bought vegetables in before composting them :-) And you shouldn't do any gardening in the same clothes that you have handled external plant material, or without washing your hands. As far as blight is concerned, you should search and destroy all other plants of the Solanaceae in your garden, both in the winter and frequently during spring. In fact, it would help to do it in an area around your garden, though that is a trifle illegal :-) Seriously. Those are all greater risks. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
|
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
"Nick Maclaren" wrote "Bob Hobden" writes: | | Yes, it's safe to compost blighted plant material, provided that | you ensure that any potato tubers in it do not survive composting | and, to a lesser extent, the blight spores are not spread from the | material on the compost heap. | | I would not take the chance, it's simply not worth the risk composting any | diseased plant material. As a statistician, that sort of thing makes me despair! You bend over backwards to minimise a negligible risk, but I will bet a guinea to a farthing that you completely ignore much more serious ones. For example, even just with composting, you should never compost UNCOOKED plant material that has come from outside and might have even been in contact with plant material. Yes, that does mean cooking any paper bags or cardboard that you have bought vegetables in before composting them :-) And you shouldn't do any gardening in the same clothes that you have handled external plant material, or without washing your hands. As far as blight is concerned, you should search and destroy all other plants of the Solanaceae in your garden, both in the winter and frequently during spring. In fact, it would help to do it in an area around your garden, though that is a trifle illegal :-) Seriously. Those are all greater risks. I appreciate that Nick, I know I am being illogical and unscientific but all my life I've had experts tell me things only to do about-turns a few years on, so in the case of diseased plant material where the possible long term contamination of my soil is at stake I will always be cautious. Besides which, knowing my luck, I'd get the mated strain that can overwinter. -- Regards Bob Hobden |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
On 16/07/08 14:57, Therefore wrote:
Hello with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant material. What opinions if any do you folks have. TIA ..........................leslie On my allotment, the experienced guys always leave the haulms to dry off and then burn them. Or they bag them up, take them home and dispose of them through the Council garden waste collection bins. They never put them on the compost heap. They just think that it is not worth taking any risks. Ed |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Blight again folks
On Thu, 17 Jul 2008 15:10:24 +0100, Ed ex@directory wrote:
On 16/07/08 14:57, Therefore wrote: Hello with regards to tomato and potato blight foliage. I have read that all foliage should be put into the dustbin and other advice to put in compost heap as blight only over winters on green plant material. What opinions if any do you folks have. TIA ..........................leslie On my allotment, the experienced guys always leave the haulms to dry off and then burn them. Or they bag them up, take them home and dispose of them through the Council garden waste collection bins. They never put them on the compost heap. They just think that it is not worth taking any risks. Ed I agree, not worth the risk. I don't grow potatoes, but many many tomatoes. I get plenty of compost material from weeds etc to risk adding known diseased material. Blighted toms go to the council. However as the spores are wind spead, like the poor it will always be with us. Better to plan for horticultural methods that make you (a little) less susceptable. That's possible with tomatoes, not really with spuds admittedly. With toms, I have found that Dithane 945 does seriously retard the infection. N |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Tomato blight again | United Kingdom | |||
Bloody VERMIN Cats again, and again, and again, and again....:-(((( | United Kingdom | |||
Blight report service(was How bad is tomato blight?) | United Kingdom | |||
Hi, saw these thought Some Folks here might find them Usefull in these dry times (url) Root Watering | Australia | |||
Thanks for the input folks. | Edible Gardening |