Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
DDT or NO DDT?
Glenna Rose wrote:
writes: James wrote: This may be off topic but considering the chemical vs organic arguement, I think it should be included here. A google of DDT and death will result in articles such as http://info-pollution.com/moreddt.htm I think we can have an interesting discussion after reading several of those articles. Is DDT more harmful than useful? DDT would be great for eradicating malaria. IMHO, malaria is the reason Africa is a backwards continent that never will amount to much. If they could beat malaria, Africa could join the 20th century -- or maybe even the 21st. g DDT is relatively non-toxic to humans, and it doesn't take much to spray the inside walls of houses to kill the mosquitoes. Developed countries that have already beaten malaria can get by without DDT. We tend to use way too much pesticides in general. Best regards, Bob I'm still wondering why there is not more widespread use of products such as mosquito dunks, they work and work very well. It seems to be a more effective method than spraying chemicals. I take special pleasure in placing them in my fish pond knowing the mosquitoes will come, lay their eggs, and end that lineage. How would the cost of providing such substances compare with the cost of DDT and other sprays? Seems killing the larvae is the key as they never get into the air to bite and breed. There must be a practical way to provide similar product (grains instead of dunks?) and spread/apply it. There is no harm to any creature or plant other than mosquito larvae. This is a sincere question. Why isn't that practice being used? Glenna I don't know; I suspect it's because of the difficulty in finding all the little pockets of water where mosquitoes can breed. The way spraying the houses works is the mosquito likes to rest a bit after feeding. So by spraying the inside walls of the houses/huts, the anopheles (sp?) mosquito that has just bitten an already infected person dies before it gets a chance to bite somebody else. So I suppose they are trying to eradicate the plasmodia parasite itself moreso than just the vector that spreads it. The lesson of DDT use in the USA is that indescrimate overuse of DDT (and probably any pesticide) is bad for the enviroment; it accumulates and concentrates in the food chain. And because of this amplification effect, we need to be careful even with low pesticide usage rates. But people like to oversimplify things and they like to blame inanimate objects as being inherently good or evil. Interesting factoid: people who are carriers of sickle-cell anemia have a natural resistance to acute malaria. Best regards, Bob |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
DDT or NO DDT?
On Date: 5 Mar 2006 09:21:55 -0800,
"James" stated: Organic seeds are in my opinion a waste of money. Organic farming doesn't not change the genetics of a plant. "zxcvbob" later, in a different thread, on Date: 12 Mar 2006, indicates: Interesting factoid: people who are carriers of sickle-cell anemia have a natural resistance to acute malaria. Meanwhile, over 100 years ago there lived a man named Charles Robert Darwin who wrote a book. Charles Darwin (12 February 1809 - 19 April 1882) wrote in 1859, "I have called this principle, by which each slight variation, if useful, is preserved, by the term Natural Selection." The full title of the book, commonly referenced as "The Origin of Species": "On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or The Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life" On a side note, a hairless man advances that he represents the next step in the evolution of man. I counter that the advancement may not amount to anything until he reproduces the trait and it displays itself in his children or grand- children. For him, some more work follows. My votes: No to DDT. No to monosodium glutamate (MSG). No to potasium benzoate and no to sodium benzoate. No to aspartame. James also stated that it would take years to go "organic". However, organic only takes one thing, work and perserverence. Last year my avocado tree produced about 60 avocadoes, the young mango tree produced 1 mango, the pineapple plant grew 1 pineapple but now I have 3 pineapple plants. The tomatoes struggled but I did get over 30 cherry tomatoes off of one vine (and its still producing) and 10 beautiful cucumbers off of several vines. I experienced aphids, slugs, bugs, butterflies, flies, misquitoes, wasps, lady bugs, and I hope to see a ton of bumble bees within the next week (the avocado tree attracts them for one or two days where they swarm over the tree). This year I'm interplanting marigold, marjoram and nasturtium in with the tomatoes, and there's now four or five mustard leaf plants. The orange tree produced bitter oranges but it produced a quite a few oranges (60 or more). The mango tree, maybe 5 years old is fully blossomed and beautiful. It pales compared to the much older mango trees in the neighbor's yard but I'm quite happy to see all these blossoms on it. Maybe I'll get 4 or 5 mangoes this year. A pineapple plant took off not far from it, and then not far from that are 4 or 5 carrots that grow very slowly (for almost a year, maybe longer). I pulled up a carrot and supposedly it grows to 12 inches, but this one only lengthed 5 inches. I need some advice on getting the carrots to grow better. Of course there's the things I'm disappointed in, the peas and the green beas tend to fail. I keep planting them, but this time I'm attempting cow-peas instead of green peas. I planted a mustard seed from a jar of mustard seeds (over four years old) and it took and bolted much quicker than the other mustard seed I planted (Florida broadleaf variety). The Florida broadleaf mustard takes a while longer to bolt but produces a lot of tasty leaves. The nasturtium tastes great and it's the first time I've ever eaten nasturtium. There's a lot of different pepper growing, and I noted that a tomato plant planted next to one pepper plant, produced a lot more peppers on that particular pepper plant. Am I mistaken, or do tomatoes benefit pepper plants (specifically a serrano pepper). In fact, I'm quite positive the serrano pepper plant benefited the tomato plant as well (cherry tomatoes from a seed taken out of a store bought cherry tomato). Jim Carlock Post replies to the group. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
DDT or NO DDT?
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
DDT or NO DDT?
|
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Article on weight gain and exposure too DDT prenatal relates to obesity | Edible Gardening | |||
DDT or NO DDT? | Edible Gardening | |||
pond, mosquitoes & DDT - potential neighbour dispute | United Kingdom |