we have just remodeled the home we live in, and needed a landscaper to do
the basics (grade the dirt and move tree's) for us.

i want to add new trees to our property and absolutely love WHITE BIRCH!
he tells us that the white birch is dying off, is that true?

--

"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...
we have just remodeled the home we live in, and needed a landscaper to do
the basics (grade the dirt and move tree's) for us.

i want to add new trees to our property and absolutely love WHITE BIRCH!
he tells us that the white birch is dying off, is that true?


Where do you live?

oh sorry!
i live in the milw. wisconsin area.
zone 5

we grew white birch quite successfully at our last house, same zone.
we hung FELS NAPTHA soap on it, and had no birch bore problem.

--



"JoeSpareBedroom" wrote in message
...
"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...
we have just remodeled the home we live in, and needed a landscaper to do
the basics (grade the dirt and move tree's) for us.

i want to add new trees to our property and absolutely love WHITE BIRCH!
he tells us that the white birch is dying off, is that true?


Where do you live?

"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...

"JoeSpareBedroom" wrote in message
...
"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...
we have just remodeled the home we live in, and needed a landscaper to
do the basics (grade the dirt and move tree's) for us.

i want to add new trees to our property and absolutely love WHITE BIRCH!
he tells us that the white birch is dying off, is that true?


Where do you live?




oh sorry!
i live in the milw. wisconsin area.
zone 5

we grew white birch quite successfully at our last house, same zone.
we hung FELS NAPTHA soap on it, and had no birch bore problem.

Go to google, and search for the words "cooperative extension wisconsin".
Contact them. The best advice for this type of thing usually comes from the
local extension service.

thanks!

--



"JoeSpareBedroom" wrote in message
...
"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...

"JoeSpareBedroom" wrote in message
...
"readandpostrosie" wrote in message
...
we have just remodeled the home we live in, and needed a landscaper to
do the basics (grade the dirt and move tree's) for us.

i want to add new trees to our property and absolutely love WHITE
BIRCH!
he tells us that the white birch is dying off, is that true?


Where do you live?




oh sorry!
i live in the milw. wisconsin area.
zone 5

we grew white birch quite successfully at our last house, same zone.
we hung FELS NAPTHA soap on it, and had no birch bore problem.

Go to google, and search for the words "cooperative extension wisconsin".
Contact them. The best advice for this type of thing usually comes from
the local extension service.

Go to google, and search for the words "cooperative extension wisconsin".
Contact them. The best advice for this type of thing usually comes from
the
local extension service.



Very interesting. When I started studying tree biology I found some of the
information by extension services disturbing. Example: They were
recommending planting birch trees in the shade and then recommending
pesticides to us for the bronze birch borer. Birches are a full sun
species. Shade them and they will have problems. BTW birches need a little
(not too much) water during dry times. Why? Because the stomata's on their
leaves are stuck open. Why? I do not know.
So anyway, I started making my own fact sheets.

Sincerely,

John A. Keslick, Jr.
Beware of so-called TREE EXPERTS who do not understand TREE BIOLOGY!
www.treedictionary.com
http://mercury.ccil.org/~treeman/
Storms, fires, floods, earthquakes, and volcanic eruptions keep reminding us
that we are not the boss.
Some people will buy products they do not understand and not buy books that
will give them understanding.

"John A. Keslick, Jr." wrote in message
...

Go to google, and search for the words "cooperative extension wisconsin".
Contact them. The best advice for this type of thing usually comes from
the
local extension service.



Very interesting. When I started studying tree biology I found some of
the
information by extension services disturbing. Example: They were
recommending planting birch trees in the shade and then recommending
pesticides to us for the bronze birch borer. Birches are a full sun
species. Shade them and they will have problems. BTW birches need a
little
(not too much) water during dry times. Why? Because the stomata's on
their
leaves are stuck open. Why? I do not know.
So anyway, I started making my own fact sheets.
John A. Keslick, Jr.


We know for a fact that 54-56% of the population is terminally stupid. Any
subset of the population is probably the same. Sounds like you found some at
those extension services.

I live in Illinois just below the Wisc. border. I planted 3 White birch
trees back in 1984 in my front yard...full sun. Turns out, after a few
years of growing, that all three were of a different variety of white
birch. They all had different sizes and shapes of leaves.
2 of the trees grew faster than the third. After 15 years the slowest
growing tree was 3" smaller in it's trunk diameter than the other 2.
That one was lost to a fungus problem causing die back from the top.
Had to remove it. The other two are now 10"+ in trunk diameter. They
are towering over my 2 story house. I had to move my sattelite dish
because they were so tall. I did have leaf miner problems when they
were younger but lately the leaf miner problem has gone away? These
trees do need special treatment. Watering during drought or even just
dry conditions. I also fertilize them
in the spring. Is weird, these last 2 trees are a different variety,
one has very white bark and the other is darker. If you keep these
trees watered the bronze birch beetle can't hurt them. The beetle bores
into the tree and if it is healthy the borer just drowns in the sap of
the tree. Any way that is the way I have been doing it and the trees
are doing great.
The neighbors just love them also. They are so nice to look at. Plus
they block the sunlight to my house in the afternoon. Wish I could post
some pics of them. They take some extra work but are well worth it.
Dan.