Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
Made the mistake of checking the ForestFarm site, and decided to go
through their list of plants. Now I have a long list of shrubs and trees I want, and am trying to figure out which ones I should order or attempt to find locally. The FF online catalog is very stingy with details, and I've tried to fill in the gaps as much as possible with info from the web, but am still unclear about which plants will do well. I have a lot of land, and the plants will go in conditions of either light shade or full sun. If there is a particular shrub that is a must have and needs more shade, I am sure I can find a spot for it. The sunny spots drain really well (on a slope), the shadier spots less well. The soil is amended clay and slightly acidic. I'm in Zone 7a, Northern VA (about 30 minutes West of DC), where the winter lows get close to 0 F, and the summers are insanely hot and humid. Oh, and we have tons of deer, so deer resistant shrubs would be preferable, although I certainly don't have any problems taking the trouble to protect the special plants. Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto' Callistemon 'Woodlander Hardy Red' Camellia 'Winter's Interlude' Chaenomeles 'Cameo' Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis' Fuschia 'Aurea' Kerria Japonica Picta Magnolia Sieboldii Myrtus communis 'Variegata' Phygelius rectus 'Sunshine' Viburnum ichangense (recommended pollinator?) Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta' Does anyone have experience with these shrubs? If you think any of these plants would be especially good (or not) for the conditions I've described above, I would love to hear about it. If you have recommendations for other shrubs I should consider (shorter shrubs are easier to find homes for), I'm all ears. Suja |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
"Suja" wrote in message
news:AEH6c.15799$Cf3.2901@lakeread01... Made the mistake of checking the ForestFarm site, and decided to go through their list of plants. Now I have a long list of shrubs and trees I want, and am trying to figure out which ones I should order or attempt to find locally. The FF online catalog is very stingy with details, and I've tried to fill in the gaps as much as possible with info from the web, but am still unclear about which plants will do well. I have a lot of land, and the plants will go in conditions of either light shade or full sun. If there is a particular shrub that is a must have and needs more shade, I am sure I can find a spot for it. The sunny spots drain really well (on a slope), the shadier spots less well. The soil is amended clay and slightly acidic. I'm in Zone 7a, Northern VA (about 30 minutes West of DC), where the winter lows get close to 0 F, and the summers are insanely hot and humid. Oh, and we have tons of deer, so deer resistant shrubs would be preferable, although I certainly don't have any problems taking the trouble to protect the special plants. Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto' Fine tree, but almost all of the palmatums do better in dappled sunshine. Certain varieties like 'Bloodgood' and 'Crimson Queen' tolerate full sun, but still will bronze out a bit. Camellia 'Winter's Interlude' All Camellia should have early morning sun protection and if possible, high shade at mid day-- under tall pines for example is a great spot. Chaenomeles 'Cameo' Fine Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis' I'm not familiar with that cultivar, but it's a fine tree for our area. Fuschia 'Aurea' Kerria Japonica Picta Picta must have good to deep shade. The shadier the better. Magnolia Sieboldii Lovely. Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta' I don't know a 'Compacta', there is a 'Compactum' that is supposed to be a fine dwarf variety. Not being anal, just make sure you are getting the shrub you want. I'm concerned with all this land that you will end of witha rather random design to the garden. Have you considered hiring a designer? Dave, also in Fairfax. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
David J Bockman wrote:
Fine tree, but almost all of the palmatums do better in dappled sunshine. Certain varieties like 'Bloodgood' and 'Crimson Queen' tolerate full sun, but still will bronze out a bit. I do have an East facing location near the house that might be better for this. I was also considering a Sango Kaku to complete a triad of trees, but the area is most definitely full sun, and now I think I should go back to my default, a standard weeping cherry. All Camellia should have early morning sun protection and if possible, high shade at mid day-- under tall pines for example is a great spot. Why early morning protection? This one will probably go against the house, on the East side. I believe that it will have shade early on because of all the other trees that are near it. Picta must have good to deep shade. The shadier the better. I realize that it likes some shade, but didn't think that it needed heavy shade. I have a fairly good (and long) treeline, and can use this to underplant, but I do want it where I can see it, and that might defeat the purpose Lovely. What I've read suggests that it might be marginally hardy in this area. Do you know if that is a problem? I don't know a 'Compacta', there is a 'Compactum' that is supposed to be a fine dwarf variety. Not being anal, just make sure you are getting the shrub you want. That's what FF called it. http://www.forestfarm.com/search/clo...lantID=vica041 I'm concerned with all this land that you will end of witha rather random design to the garden. Have you considered hiring a designer? I don't think that the garden will lack cohesion, because I do have a master plan, although I am doing it a little bit at a time. The reason I haven't asked for professional help is primarily because I'm a wannabe gardner (I only have 5 or 6 years of experience total), and I learn best by doing. The other problem of course is that what I want is generally not what you see in these parts, a bunch of low maintenance evergreens bordered by liriope. Not to say that a designer can't help, just that I have not seen a garden in anyone's home that I've really coveted in these parts. Too cookie cutter for me. Besides, I'm a cottage gardner at heart, and would most likely give the designing sorts a few heart attacks. I like barely organized chaos. Eventually, I will probably need guidance from some sort of a designer, because about 80% of my property is in shade, and I'd be waay out of my league when it comes to woodland gardening. Any ideas on where I can get all this stuff? I am hoping to find sources locally (I'll check Merrifield and Betty's) so that I don't have to pay FF's shipping charges. Suja |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
"Suja" wrote in message news:QJM6c.16235$Cf3.12529@lakeread01... David J Bockman wrote: Fine tree, but almost all of the palmatums do better in dappled sunshine. Certain varieties like 'Bloodgood' and 'Crimson Queen' tolerate full sun, but still will bronze out a bit. I do have an East facing location near the house that might be better for this. I was also considering a Sango Kaku to complete a triad of trees, but the area is most definitely full sun, and now I think I should go back to my default, a standard weeping cherry. Being the nosy enthusiast type, I'll suggest trying to find Prunus subhirtella 'Pendula' not on a standard, but growing on its own rootstock. MUCH more picturesque as the tree ages. All Camellia should have early morning sun protection and if possible, high shade at mid day-- under tall pines for example is a great spot. Why early morning protection? This one will probably go against the house, on the East side. I believe that it will have shade early on because of all the other trees that are near it. All Camelias, even the more winter-hardy Ackerman hybrids such as 'Winter's Interlude', are susceptible to early morning 'leaf blast' when temperatures dip below freezing and subsequently the leaves are exposed to early morning direct sun. The thick leaves retain a lot of moisture which needs time to thaw under warming air temperatures, not direct sunlight, or else the cell walls rupture and the leaf blackens and dies. Picta must have good to deep shade. The shadier the better. I realize that it likes some shade, but didn't think that it needed heavy shade. I have a fairly good (and long) treeline, and can use this to underplant, but I do want it where I can see it, and that might defeat the purpose. Don't need heavy shade per se, but any substantial length of direct sun (say, more than 2-3 hours, less if at midday) will scorch. Lovely. What I've read suggests that it might be marginally hardy in this area. Do you know if that is a problem? (With regard to Magnolia seiboldii) I haven't seen it grown in our area all that often, doesn't mean it won't do well here. Dirr lists it as Zones 6-8, so it should be fine. The best location would be 'semi-shady', strong dappled sunshine. I don't know a 'Compacta', there is a 'Compactum' that is supposed to be a fine dwarf variety. Not being anal, just make sure you are getting the shrub you want. That's what FF called it. http://www.forestfarm.com/search/clo...lantID=vica041 Hmm..Perhaps it's a Forest Farm introduction or they just misspelled slightly. Looks lovely. Any ideas on where I can get all this stuff? I am hoping to find sources locally (I'll check Merrifield and Betty's) so that I don't have to pay FF's shipping charges. Yes, two good places to start. You can get their fax numbers and just fax the whole list over, they can call you back or return fax availability and prices. Best not to do it on a weekend, however. Unless you spec out the exact sizes and 'styles' of each tree/shrub you are looking for, you'll get whatever they have (for example, if you went with my suggestion on the Prunus, and didn't spec 'own rootstock', you'd most likely get a standard.) Dave |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
"Suja" wrote in message news:QJM6c.16235$Cf3.12529@lakeread01... David J Bockman wrote: Fine tree, but almost all of the palmatums do better in dappled sunshine. Certain varieties like 'Bloodgood' and 'Crimson Queen' tolerate full sun, but still will bronze out a bit. I do have an East facing location near the house that might be better for this. I was also considering a Sango Kaku to complete a triad of trees, but the area is most definitely full sun, and now I think I should go back to my default, a standard weeping cherry. Being the nosy enthusiast type, I'll suggest trying to find Prunus subhirtella 'Pendula' not on a standard, but growing on its own rootstock. MUCH more picturesque as the tree ages. All Camellia should have early morning sun protection and if possible, high shade at mid day-- under tall pines for example is a great spot. Why early morning protection? This one will probably go against the house, on the East side. I believe that it will have shade early on because of all the other trees that are near it. All Camelias, even the more winter-hardy Ackerman hybrids such as 'Winter's Interlude', are susceptible to early morning 'leaf blast' when temperatures dip below freezing and subsequently the leaves are exposed to early morning direct sun. The thick leaves retain a lot of moisture which needs time to thaw under warming air temperatures, not direct sunlight, or else the cell walls rupture and the leaf blackens and dies. Picta must have good to deep shade. The shadier the better. I realize that it likes some shade, but didn't think that it needed heavy shade. I have a fairly good (and long) treeline, and can use this to underplant, but I do want it where I can see it, and that might defeat the purpose. Don't need heavy shade per se, but any substantial length of direct sun (say, more than 2-3 hours, less if at midday) will scorch. Lovely. What I've read suggests that it might be marginally hardy in this area. Do you know if that is a problem? (With regard to Magnolia seiboldii) I haven't seen it grown in our area all that often, doesn't mean it won't do well here. Dirr lists it as Zones 6-8, so it should be fine. The best location would be 'semi-shady', strong dappled sunshine. I don't know a 'Compacta', there is a 'Compactum' that is supposed to be a fine dwarf variety. Not being anal, just make sure you are getting the shrub you want. That's what FF called it. http://www.forestfarm.com/search/clo...lantID=vica041 Hmm..Perhaps it's a Forest Farm introduction or they just misspelled slightly. Looks lovely. Any ideas on where I can get all this stuff? I am hoping to find sources locally (I'll check Merrifield and Betty's) so that I don't have to pay FF's shipping charges. Yes, two good places to start. You can get their fax numbers and just fax the whole list over, they can call you back or return fax availability and prices. Best not to do it on a weekend, however. Unless you spec out the exact sizes and 'styles' of each tree/shrub you are looking for, you'll get whatever they have (for example, if you went with my suggestion on the Prunus, and didn't spec 'own rootstock', you'd most likely get a standard.) Dave |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
Suja,
Based on my experience: Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto': nice dwarf A.palmatum. There are many similiar A.palmatums, all nice. Mine are eaten more by rabbits than deer. I have to put a cage around small ones for about three years to let them get big enough to withstand winter rabbit munching Camellia 'Winter's Interlude': one of the many Ackerman hybrids. I have had no deer damage to mine in ten years. Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis': I had one that I removed. The spiral growth habit is a matter of perception, to my eye there was very little spiraling. No deer or rabbit damage. Magnolia Sieboldii: my favorite magnolia. Deer will remove some winter buds. Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta': wonderful small shrub. I can't understand why this plant is not more popular. No deer damage in ten years. Hope this helps, --beeky Suja wrote: Made the mistake of checking the ForestFarm site, and decided to go through their list of plants. Now I have a long list of shrubs and trees I want, and am trying to figure out which ones I should order or attempt to find locally. The FF online catalog is very stingy with details, and I've tried to fill in the gaps as much as possible with info from the web, but am still unclear about which plants will do well. I have a lot of land, and the plants will go in conditions of either light shade or full sun. If there is a particular shrub that is a must have and needs more shade, I am sure I can find a spot for it. The sunny spots drain really well (on a slope), the shadier spots less well. The soil is amended clay and slightly acidic. I'm in Zone 7a, Northern VA (about 30 minutes West of DC), where the winter lows get close to 0 F, and the summers are insanely hot and humid. Oh, and we have tons of deer, so deer resistant shrubs would be preferable, although I certainly don't have any problems taking the trouble to protect the special plants. Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto' Callistemon 'Woodlander Hardy Red' Camellia 'Winter's Interlude' Chaenomeles 'Cameo' Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis' Fuschia 'Aurea' Kerria Japonica Picta Magnolia Sieboldii Myrtus communis 'Variegata' Phygelius rectus 'Sunshine' Viburnum ichangense (recommended pollinator?) Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta' Does anyone have experience with these shrubs? If you think any of these plants would be especially good (or not) for the conditions I've described above, I would love to hear about it. If you have recommendations for other shrubs I should consider (shorter shrubs are easier to find homes for), I'm all ears. Suja |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
Suja,
Based on my experience: Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto': nice dwarf A.palmatum. There are many similiar A.palmatums, all nice. Mine are eaten more by rabbits than deer. I have to put a cage around small ones for about three years to let them get big enough to withstand winter rabbit munching Camellia 'Winter's Interlude': one of the many Ackerman hybrids. I have had no deer damage to mine in ten years. Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis': I had one that I removed. The spiral growth habit is a matter of perception, to my eye there was very little spiraling. No deer or rabbit damage. Magnolia Sieboldii: my favorite magnolia. Deer will remove some winter buds. Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta': wonderful small shrub. I can't understand why this plant is not more popular. No deer damage in ten years. Hope this helps, --beeky Suja wrote: Made the mistake of checking the ForestFarm site, and decided to go through their list of plants. Now I have a long list of shrubs and trees I want, and am trying to figure out which ones I should order or attempt to find locally. The FF online catalog is very stingy with details, and I've tried to fill in the gaps as much as possible with info from the web, but am still unclear about which plants will do well. I have a lot of land, and the plants will go in conditions of either light shade or full sun. If there is a particular shrub that is a must have and needs more shade, I am sure I can find a spot for it. The sunny spots drain really well (on a slope), the shadier spots less well. The soil is amended clay and slightly acidic. I'm in Zone 7a, Northern VA (about 30 minutes West of DC), where the winter lows get close to 0 F, and the summers are insanely hot and humid. Oh, and we have tons of deer, so deer resistant shrubs would be preferable, although I certainly don't have any problems taking the trouble to protect the special plants. Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto' Callistemon 'Woodlander Hardy Red' Camellia 'Winter's Interlude' Chaenomeles 'Cameo' Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis' Fuschia 'Aurea' Kerria Japonica Picta Magnolia Sieboldii Myrtus communis 'Variegata' Phygelius rectus 'Sunshine' Viburnum ichangense (recommended pollinator?) Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta' Does anyone have experience with these shrubs? If you think any of these plants would be especially good (or not) for the conditions I've described above, I would love to hear about it. If you have recommendations for other shrubs I should consider (shorter shrubs are easier to find homes for), I'm all ears. Suja |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
David J Bockman wrote:
Being the nosy enthusiast type, I'll suggest trying to find Prunus subhirtella 'Pendula' not on a standard, but growing on its own rootstock. MUCH more picturesque as the tree ages. What's the difference? For example, the one at FF says 'on serrula trunk' (http://www.forestfarm.com/search/clo...lantID=prsu045) and makes it sound like that's a good thing. The tree person at Merrifield who recommended it to me said that I can expect it to get rather tall - does the rootstock make a difference in size? All Camelias, even the more winter-hardy Ackerman hybrids such as 'Winter's Interlude', are susceptible to early morning 'leaf blast' when temperatures dip below freezing and subsequently the leaves are exposed to early morning direct sun. The thick leaves retain a lot of moisture which needs time to thaw under warming air temperatures, not direct sunlight, or else the cell walls rupture and the leaf blackens and dies. Thanks. I didn't know that. I'll have to watch the spot more closely to see how soon it gets sun and how long it stays there. Don't need heavy shade per se, but any substantial length of direct sun (say, more than 2-3 hours, less if at midday) will scorch. That, I didn't know. I will see if I can find a good dappled shade spot for it. Yes, two good places to start. You can get their fax numbers and just fax the whole list over, they can call you back or return fax availability and prices. Best not to do it on a weekend, however. Unless you spec out the exact sizes and 'styles' of each tree/shrub you are looking for, you'll get whatever they have (for example, if you went with my suggestion on the Prunus, and didn't spec 'own rootstock', you'd most likely get a standard.) That's a really good idea. I have generally called in my requests or gone in person during a weekday. I don't particularly care for Betty's staff - the ones manning the store are fine, but the ones outside don't know what they're talking about. I've never been able to get decent recommendations out of them. For that matter, I haven't been able to get anyone to even spend a little bit of time with me, talking about their stock. IIRC, you work for a nursery in this area, right? If you don't mind, could you let me know where? Email is fine, if you don't want to put the information out on usenet. Suja |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
David J Bockman wrote:
Being the nosy enthusiast type, I'll suggest trying to find Prunus subhirtella 'Pendula' not on a standard, but growing on its own rootstock. MUCH more picturesque as the tree ages. What's the difference? For example, the one at FF says 'on serrula trunk' (http://www.forestfarm.com/search/clo...lantID=prsu045) and makes it sound like that's a good thing. The tree person at Merrifield who recommended it to me said that I can expect it to get rather tall - does the rootstock make a difference in size? All Camelias, even the more winter-hardy Ackerman hybrids such as 'Winter's Interlude', are susceptible to early morning 'leaf blast' when temperatures dip below freezing and subsequently the leaves are exposed to early morning direct sun. The thick leaves retain a lot of moisture which needs time to thaw under warming air temperatures, not direct sunlight, or else the cell walls rupture and the leaf blackens and dies. Thanks. I didn't know that. I'll have to watch the spot more closely to see how soon it gets sun and how long it stays there. Don't need heavy shade per se, but any substantial length of direct sun (say, more than 2-3 hours, less if at midday) will scorch. That, I didn't know. I will see if I can find a good dappled shade spot for it. Yes, two good places to start. You can get their fax numbers and just fax the whole list over, they can call you back or return fax availability and prices. Best not to do it on a weekend, however. Unless you spec out the exact sizes and 'styles' of each tree/shrub you are looking for, you'll get whatever they have (for example, if you went with my suggestion on the Prunus, and didn't spec 'own rootstock', you'd most likely get a standard.) That's a really good idea. I have generally called in my requests or gone in person during a weekday. I don't particularly care for Betty's staff - the ones manning the store are fine, but the ones outside don't know what they're talking about. I've never been able to get decent recommendations out of them. For that matter, I haven't been able to get anyone to even spend a little bit of time with me, talking about their stock. IIRC, you work for a nursery in this area, right? If you don't mind, could you let me know where? Email is fine, if you don't want to put the information out on usenet. Suja |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Which shrubs to choose?
Suja wrote:
Made the mistake of checking the ForestFarm site, and decided to go through their list of plants. Now I have a long list of shrubs and trees I want, and am trying to figure out which ones I should order or attempt to find locally. The FF online catalog is very stingy with details, and I've tried to fill in the gaps as much as possible with info from the web, but am still unclear about which plants will do well. I have a lot of land, and the plants will go in conditions of either light shade or full sun. If there is a particular shrub that is a must have and needs more shade, I am sure I can find a spot for it. The sunny spots drain really well (on a slope), the shadier spots less well. The soil is amended clay and slightly acidic. I'm in Zone 7a, Northern VA (about 30 minutes West of DC), where the winter lows get close to 0 F, and the summers are insanely hot and humid. Oh, and we have tons of deer, so deer resistant shrubs would be preferable, although I certainly don't have any problems taking the trouble to protect the special plants. Acer palmatum 'Villa Taranto' Callistemon 'Woodlander Hardy Red' Camellia 'Winter's Interlude' Chaenomeles 'Cameo' Cryptomeria Japonica 'Spiralis' Fuschia 'Aurea' Kerria Japonica Picta Magnolia Sieboldii Myrtus communis 'Variegata' Phygelius rectus 'Sunshine' Viburnum ichangense (recommended pollinator?) Viburnum carlesii 'Compacta' Does anyone have experience with these shrubs? If you think any of these plants would be especially good (or not) for the conditions I've described above, I would love to hear about it. If you have recommendations for other shrubs I should consider (shorter shrubs are easier to find homes for), I'm all ears. In the "other shrubs" category, let me name some favorites: Viburnum plicatum tomentosum -- doublefile viburnum -- gorgeous flowering in spring -- a really pretty shrub. V. bracteatum 'Emerald lustrer' -- shiny green leaves, some flowering, colorful berries. V. bodnantense -- clusters of pink, fragrant flowers in early spring, before the leaves appear. (Most of the viburnums are tough as nails.) Ternstroemia gymnanthera (Japanese cleyera) -- in the tea family, like Camellia, and blends well with them. Camellia oleifera (the tea-oil camellia) and C. sinensis (the tea plant) are said to be hardy to zone 6. Less showy than some other Camellias, but still attractive. Camellia sasanqua -- you have to be careful, but some are hardy in your zone. I prefer their open habit to that of C. japonica. The tricky thing is that Camellias need excellent drainage, yet most like some shade, so you will need to be creative in how and where you plant them. Most crape myrtles are said to be hardy to your zone. They are tough and take heat and humidity well. Look for the mildew-resistant varieties. Some are small trees, others are shrubby. Lonicera fragrantissima (winter honeysuckle) will fill a lot of space and smells wonderful in late winter and early spring. Not invasive like some other honeysuckles. Have fun! Mike Prager Beaufort, NC (on the coast in zone 8a) (Remove spam traps from email address to reply.) |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
help me choose some plants for a tricky garden spot | United Kingdom | |||
help me choose some plants for a tricky garden spot | United Kingdom | |||
How to choose (limit) roses? | Roses | |||
a pump the fish would choose? | Ponds | |||
Help me choose good ones for this area? | Roses |