Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this
group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Melanie |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
"Melanie Sands" wrote
Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Firstly you have opened a can or worms. Personally myself I want cats in my garden and certainly on my allotment, damn mice/voles have eaten a lot of our potatoes this year because the houses round about our plot do not have any cats. Our previous allotment had 27 cats quite close by at the Swan Sanctuary and we never had any problem with mice/voles or pigeons. Got hit by a swan on takeoff though. -- Regards. Bob Hobden. Posted to this Newsgroup from the W of London, UK |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On Sep 9, 1:43*pm, Melanie Sands wrote:
Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially *in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Melanie Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. I don't suppose they notice. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On 10/09/2011 07:14, harry wrote:
On Sep 9, 1:43 pm, Melanie wrote: Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Melanie Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. I don't suppose they notice. Rake a fine tilth, sew your seeds, then in the morning find a cat has visited and spoilt a lot of your hard work. -- Residing on low ground in North Staffordshire |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
"Moonraker" wrote
Rake a fine tilth, sew your seeds, then in the morning find a cat has visited and spoilt a lot of your hard work. I'd much rather that than lose all your crops to mice/voles/rats, at least you can replant straight away and put some wire netting over the bed to stop it happening again. Not much you can do about all rodents, but a cat can. -- Regards. Bob Hobden. Posted to this Newsgroup from the W of London, UK |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
In article ,
alan.holmes wrote: Cats are as natural as any othe animal and they are native to this country, unlike the grey squirrel! Er, no. The native cat is either a different species or a VERY different subspecies. The problem with cats is that they are provided with food and shelter, thus enabling a density of population hundreds (or, more probably, thousands) of times higher than would occur in nature. And, despite your claims, they are are much greater threat to small birds than grey squirrels are. Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
"harry" wrote in message ... On Sep 9, 1:43 pm, Melanie Sands wrote: Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop:http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Melanie Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. I don't suppose they notice. I always knew there was something wrong with my nose, I have had cats around me since I was very small, and I have never, ever had any trouble with them smelling, in fact when I was small, female cats in those days always produced loads of kittens as operating on them to stop that was not easily done, vets cost a lot of money and most people could not afford that, in those days small boys were always dressed in pinafores which had a large pocket in the front, when our cats had fed the kittens I always took them and put them into the pocket and carried them with me until the parent cat wanted to fed them, then I passed the kittens back to her, and again when she had finnished feeding them I picked them up again back to the pocket! Cats are as natural as any othe animal and they are native to this country, unlike the grey squirrel! The real menace to our wildlife is the grey squirrel which plunders birds nests damaging the eggs and killing the young birds! Alan |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
There are enough repeats on the Beeb. If it will help to save people
the effort of repeating themselves ad nauseam, I can repost the content of earlier threads on this subject. :~ Cheers Jake ============================================== Gardening at the less wet end of Swansea Bay but moved on from Tolkien; now half way through the complete Harry Potter. www.rivendell.org.uk |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
Jake Nospam@invalid wrote in news:vc4n67ped33i58bnldqhb8i4j8csih06na@
4ax.com: There are enough repeats on the Beeb. If it will help to save people the effort of repeating themselves ad nauseam, I can repost the content of earlier threads on this subject. :~ Cheers Jake ============================================== Gardening at the less wet end of Swansea Bay but moved on from Tolkien; now half way through the complete Harry Potter. www.rivendell.org.uk Jake, Simply, don't read them. Ignore the thread and move on. To be honest, I like the thread and will read all of the views, repeated or not, because I have a dislike of cats, they make my skin crawl and I as a UK citizen I should be able to go about my day to day life without them, and fouling my garden where I grow things to eat. We have lots of strays here, too many for the local council and rescue agencies to handle because of the breeding habits and the irresponsible former and current owners attitude. I feel very strongly about this subject, and it is on topic. Baz |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
"Bob Hobden" wrote in
: Got hit by a swan on takeoff though. Where were you going to, Bob? Hope you landed ok. Baz |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On Sep 9, 2:03*pm, "Bob Hobden" wrote:
"Melanie Sands" *wrote Okay, so I've done a bit of googling and snooping in the posts in this group to find out why. There's much talk about "crap" and "poo" - but are you sure it's not HEDGEHOGS that are doing the dirty? We have an office/workshop surrounded by fields and allotment gardens / community gardens. Often, cats come by and especially *in the winter when it's really cold (I live in Switzerland) I feed them, thinking (wrongly) that if they don't have a collar they must be wild/stray cats. Come summer, many of the garden allotment folks also feed the cats with barbeque sausages etc., but others poison them or, as one gardener told me, he "presses their heads down into the soil until they are kaputt". Over the past 6 years, over 12 cats suddenly disappeared: on this page there is a pixture of our "gazebo" on our parking lot, where I have potted plants, and the only animals who crap there are said hedgehogs. The cats were always very tidy: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo.html Latest disappearance victim is my own cat Büsli who was not only sweet and affectionate and followed me round like a dog, but was also an expert mouse-catcher - very useful as we have food in ourfice/workshop: http://roundtablespage.tvheaven.com/photo2.html so I'm wondering - do gardeners WANT mice? I just don't understand the fuss. If you like nature, surely you like nature's creatures - especially such useful ones and low-maintenance ones! Firstly you have opened a can or worms. Personally myself I want cats in my garden and certainly on my allotment, damn mice/voles have eaten a lot of our potatoes this year because the houses round about our plot do not have any cats. Our previous allotment had 27 cats quite close by at the Swan Sanctuary and we never had any problem with mice/voles or pigeons. Got hit by a swan on takeoff though. -- Regards. Bob Hobden. Posted to this Newsgroup from the W of London, UK- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I could give a list as long as your arm of well known and good gardeners who have/had cats around them in their gardens and a great many more who probably wouldn't rank as well known or good - you can add me to that list. Beyond that I won't rise to the usual cat hating suspects or the trolls, Besides that I've probably had more companionship and pleasure from cats than I have had from people (No, I don't hate people - not many of them anyway) Rod |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On 10 Sep., 08:14, harry wrote:
Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. *They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. Go ahead, put all the animals in cages. No more free-flying birds! Then they won't poop on our cars or fly into our airplanes! No more free-swimming fish in the ocean, then they won't eat us! No more insects in the air, then they won't sting us or fly into our nostrils and land in our drinks and settle on our picnic-food! They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. Ah - now finally I understand why SOME gardeners are behind fences! *You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, Yes, unfortunately. Extremely unnatural situation nowadays. Pigs not allowed to run out into the field, but have to slip around on shite-covered concrete floors, each calf torn away from its cow-mother after 6 weeks, cows tied up by their tails in the barn, chickens cooped up in horrid sheds, rabbits in cages the size of two sheets of paper... Human beings really are shite to animals. why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. *You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. That's because they are locked up and forced to pee into a non-flushing toilet, instead of being able to do their stuff outside and cover it up with sand/earth, as free-running cats DO. Of course, our own, human toilets always smell of Chanel Nr. 5 when we go to the loo...in fact, we humans always smell just wonderful, whether it's our breath, our armpits, our private parts, our scalps, our feet - nothing like all those smelly animals, euwwh! As for cats wrecking a fresh flower bed or freshly planted seeds - bullshit! I've planted seeds and forgot to cover the pots with netting, and the next day I saw crows and smaller black-coloured birds digging up the seeds with their beaks and tossing the earth around everywhere, and by the time I went outside, narry a seed was left in the pots. I berated myself for being such an amateur, and thought how every professional gardener knows one has to cover a freshly- planted bed with protective netting till the seeds had started to push through the earth! BTW, I read on a previous cat thread about a woman watching two cats "crapping on her lawn". The cats were quite right. A lawn is an abomination! If someone gave me a lawn, I'd instantly mix a few kilos of various flower seeds and scatter them over the grass and water them to get a lovely multi-coloured mini-meadow one can really sink one's feet into! Low-maintenance and so much better for the environment, too. By the way, if those community-gardeners at our office were less interested in guzzling beer/barbequeing/burning wet leaves (which is against the law) on their allotments and more interested in picking up the pears, peaches, apples and grapes that rot on the ground under their trees, and cutting their cabbages and lettuce before it all shoots up half a metre, I'd maybe take them seriously as gardeners, instead of as the AA-reject animal murderers they are. Oh, and by the way - since I put out bowls of milk and canned, meaty cat food, the long brown slugs have left off eating my plants and drink the milk and gulp down the cat food. Works better than beer and slug poison! Melanie |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On Sep 11, 2:47*pm, Melanie Sands wrote:
On 10 Sep., 08:14, harry wrote: Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. *They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. Go ahead, put all the animals in cages. No more free-flying birds! Then they won't poop on our cars or fly into our airplanes! No more free-swimming fish in the ocean, then they won't eat us! No more insects in the air, then they won't sting us or fly into our nostrils and land in our drinks and settle on our picnic-food! They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. Ah - now finally I understand why SOME gardeners are behind fences! *You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, Yes, unfortunately. Extremely unnatural situation nowadays. Pigs not allowed to run out into the field, but have to slip around on shite-covered concrete floors, each calf torn away from its cow-mother after 6 weeks, cows tied up by their tails in the barn, chickens cooped up in horrid sheds, rabbits in cages the size of two sheets of paper... Human beings really are shite to animals. why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. *You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. That's because they are locked up and forced to pee into a non-flushing toilet, instead of being able to do their stuff outside and cover it up with sand/earth, as free-running cats DO. Of course, our own, human toilets always smell of Chanel Nr. 5 when we go to the loo...in fact, we humans always smell just wonderful, whether it's our breath, our armpits, our private parts, our scalps, our feet - nothing like all those smelly animals, euwwh! As for cats wrecking a fresh flower bed or freshly planted seeds - bullshit! I've planted seeds and forgot to cover the pots with netting, and the next day I saw crows and smaller black-coloured birds digging up the seeds with their beaks and tossing the earth around everywhere, and by the time I went outside, narry a seed was left in the pots. I berated myself for being such an amateur, and thought how every professional gardener knows one has to cover a freshly- planted bed with protective netting till the seeds had started to push through the earth! BTW, I read on a previous cat thread about a woman watching two cats "crapping on her lawn". The cats were quite right. A lawn is an abomination! If someone gave me a lawn, I'd instantly mix a few kilos of various flower seeds and scatter them over the grass and water them to get a lovely multi-coloured mini-meadow one can really sink one's feet into! Low-maintenance and so much better for the environment, too. By the way, if those community-gardeners at our office were less interested in guzzling beer/barbequeing/burning wet leaves (which is against the law) on their allotments and more interested in picking up the pears, peaches, apples and grapes that rot on the ground under their trees, and cutting their cabbages and lettuce before it all shoots up half a metre, I'd maybe take them seriously as gardeners, instead of as the AA-reject animal murderers they are. Oh, and by the way - since I put out bowls of milk and canned, meaty cat food, the long brown slugs have left off eating my plants and drink the milk and gulp down the cat food. Works better than beer and slug poison! Melanie Aha.You are a nutcase. Thought so. Cats are not native to this country, they are mere pets. Introducing/ freeing non-native animals is always a mistake. So if you want one, keep it securely locked up. If you leave it run free, don't be surprised if someone takes it into their heads to deal with it if it becames a nuisance. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Why do gardeners hate cats?
On Sep 11, 2:47*pm, Melanie Sands wrote:
On 10 Sep., 08:14, harry wrote: Cat s are not natures creatures. They are a feral menace to our wildlife. *They don't belong in our countryside/gardens. I don't understand why cat owners own cats or leave them run loose. Go ahead, put all the animals in cages. No more free-flying birds! Then they won't poop on our cars or fly into our airplanes! No more free-swimming fish in the ocean, then they won't eat us! No more insects in the air, then they won't sting us or fly into our nostrils and land in our drinks and settle on our picnic-food! They should be kept in cages ike a hamster or fenced in. Ah - now finally I understand why SOME gardeners are behind fences! *You can't leave a horse or a dog run loose, Yes, unfortunately. Extremely unnatural situation nowadays. Pigs not allowed to run out into the field, but have to slip around on shite-covered concrete floors, each calf torn away from its cow-mother after 6 weeks, cows tied up by their tails in the barn, chickens cooped up in horrid sheds, rabbits in cages the size of two sheets of paper... Human beings really are shite to animals. why should a cat be let run loose? Nasty smelly things. *You can always tell when there is a cat in someone's house by the stench when you walk in the door. That's because they are locked up and forced to pee into a non-flushing toilet, instead of being able to do their stuff outside and cover it up with sand/earth, as free-running cats DO. Of course, our own, human toilets always smell of Chanel Nr. 5 when we go to the loo...in fact, we humans always smell just wonderful, whether it's our breath, our armpits, our private parts, our scalps, our feet - nothing like all those smelly animals, euwwh! As for cats wrecking a fresh flower bed or freshly planted seeds - bullshit! I've planted seeds and forgot to cover the pots with netting, and the next day I saw crows and smaller black-coloured birds digging up the seeds with their beaks and tossing the earth around everywhere, and by the time I went outside, narry a seed was left in the pots. I berated myself for being such an amateur, and thought how every professional gardener knows one has to cover a freshly- planted bed with protective netting till the seeds had started to push through the earth! BTW, I read on a previous cat thread about a woman watching two cats "crapping on her lawn". The cats were quite right. A lawn is an abomination! If someone gave me a lawn, I'd instantly mix a few kilos of various flower seeds and scatter them over the grass and water them to get a lovely multi-coloured mini-meadow one can really sink one's feet into! Low-maintenance and so much better for the environment, too. By the way, if those community-gardeners at our office were less interested in guzzling beer/barbequeing/burning wet leaves (which is against the law) on their allotments and more interested in picking up the pears, peaches, apples and grapes that rot on the ground under their trees, and cutting their cabbages and lettuce before it all shoots up half a metre, I'd maybe take them seriously as gardeners, instead of as the AA-reject animal murderers they are. Oh, and by the way - since I put out bowls of milk and canned, meaty cat food, the long brown slugs have left off eating my plants and drink the milk and gulp down the cat food. Works better than beer and slug poison! Melanie I see you know absolutely nothing about lawns, grass or meadows too. In short, you are an uneducated half wit. |
Reply |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Why ? Why ? Why? | United Kingdom | |||
Why I hate Winter! - unchained.jpg (1/1) | Garden Photos | |||
Why I hate winter - attached files (1/1) | Garden Photos | |||
Gardeners are gardeners | United Kingdom | |||
why did Sharon cook with all the potters? We can't hate dogs unless John will slowly comb afterwards | United Kingdom |