Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
JennyC wrote: And just to confuse you even more................... http://library.thinkquest.org/C007974/ Cannabis? Well I never ... someone must call Frank! |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
"luke" wrote in message
ups.com... i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade (atropa belladona) i just dont know Not the *most* poisonous, but a genus I avoid assiduously is the Rhus (Poison Ivy family). Even the ubiquitous Stag's Horn Sumach has been said to put nursery workers in hospital, though I have no confirmation of this. I can speak for a very unpleasant personal experience with a less common one, R. verniciflua - this is the plant the Japanese laquer was made from. The trees I encountered were already dead when I started work here just over 30 years ago, in my innocence I started cutting them up for firewood. The yellowish coloured wood exudes a black tarry substance and we all got it on our hands and clothes. I and my then teenage daughter reacted very severely, whole body swelling, violently itching rash, closed eyes - luckily no blocked airways. I couldn't walk or drive and sensitive areas didn't clear until treated with steroid cream. All the doc could do was to say was that something hadn't agreed with us and prescribe the cream. Given the violence of the reaction I have considered it very unwise to risk contact with anything similar since. My wife was unaffected. -- Rod My real address is rodthegardeneratmyisp |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
In message , Sacha
writes On 3/12/06 20:20, in article . com, "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Almost certainly Ricinus, the castor bean, the castor oil plant. But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. It need not have been all that toxic. Ness Botanic Gardens had Deadly Nightshade and Hensbane growing accesible to all and sundry, but the Giant Hogweed was immured behind a double fence. -- Stewart Robert Hinsley |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
In message , Bob Hobden
writes "luke" wrote i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know I would have thought some of the Fungi would be the most poisonous plants in the world but it depends on your criteria, are you asking for the quickest, the most certain, the nastiest...... The "Destroying Angel" or "Deaths Cap" toadstool will kill you slowly and painfully over about a week as your vital organs close down, and there is not much chance of survival after the symptoms show which is some considerable time after eating them. See http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~mow/chap40.html and Amatoxins half way down. Fungi are not considered to be plants anymore. In fact, the consensus (the situation is not completely clear cut) is that fungi are more closely related to animals that to plants. -- Stewart Robert Hinsley |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
In article , Stewart Robert Hinsley writes: | | Fungi are not considered to be plants anymore. In fact, the consensus | (the situation is not completely clear cut) is that fungi are more | closely related to animals that to plants. If I understand it, that is clear-cut compared to the opinions on cellular slime-moulds, let alone plasmodial ones! Regards, Nick Maclaren. |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
Sacha wrote:
On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. .. But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. Sounds a case of alloah - goodbyah. |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
Sacha wrote:
On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. .. But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. Sounds a case of alloah - goodbyah. |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
sam wrote:
Sacha wrote: On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. . But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. Sounds a case of alloah - goodbyah. Please forgive my stammer.. |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
On 4/12/06 20:31, in article , "sam"
wrote: Sacha wrote: On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. . But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. Sounds a case of alloah - goodbyah. Possibly. If it was Aloha. -- Sacha http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk South Devon http://www.discoverdartmoor.co.uk/ |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
On 4/12/06 21:45, in article , "K"
wrote: Sacha writes On 4/12/06 00:06, in article , "Duncan" wrote: "luke" wrote in message ups.com... i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Castor bean seems a good candidate, but some other nasties include Oleander (said to be able to kill if twigs are used as barbecue skewers) and monkshood (but I'm still here despite my parents having a garden full of this). Alnwick garden have a good poisonous plants collection, and apparently someone was hospitalised after just sniffing the henbane. but Nicotiana probably kills more than all the other poisonous plants put together. Have there been any reported cases in UK? I presume he's referring to deaths from the cured dried leaves. Of what? He asked for the most toxic plant. My reply has been snipped so as to alter its original meaning. I wrote: " Have there been any reported cases in UK? I didn't think anyone had died of accidental plant poisoning (according to the RHS) for a very long time." I was not referring to Nicotiana or any other plant speifically. What exactly is meant by 'the most toxic'? The one which has killed the most? The one with the highest concentration of the poisonous substance? What would be your thinking? -- Sacha http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk South Devon http://www.discoverdartmoor.co.uk/ |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
On 4/12/06 18:36, in article lid, "Stewart Robert
Hinsley" wrote: In message , Sacha writes On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Almost certainly Ricinus, the castor bean, the castor oil plant. But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. It need not have been all that toxic. Ness Botanic Gardens had Deadly Nightshade and Hensbane growing accesible to all and sundry, but the Giant Hogweed was immured behind a double fence. WHAT might not have been all that toxic? I don't know which plants were in that enclosure. All we were told was "don't even think about getting off the bus", which was one of those open sided things. I can't remember the name of the garden just now - McKinlay, perhaps? I'll look it up tomorrow. But that particular area of that garden was used in experimentation with toxic plans and quite understandably, they didn't want the public wandering around in it. If I can find it online tomorrow I might be able to be more specific and for now, I'm sorry to be so vague! -- Sacha http://www.hillhousenursery.co.uk South Devon http://www.discoverdartmoor.co.uk/ |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
Sacha writes
On 4/12/06 21:45, in article , "K" wrote: Sacha writes On 4/12/06 00:06, in article , "Duncan" wrote: "luke" wrote in message ups.com... i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Castor bean seems a good candidate, but some other nasties include Oleander (said to be able to kill if twigs are used as barbecue skewers) and monkshood (but I'm still here despite my parents having a garden full of this). Alnwick garden have a good poisonous plants collection, and apparently someone was hospitalised after just sniffing the henbane. but Nicotiana probably kills more than all the other poisonous plants put together. Have there been any reported cases in UK? I presume he's referring to deaths from the cured dried leaves. Of what? He asked for the most toxic plant. Not the OP - I meant the guy who mentioned the Nicotiana My reply has been snipped so as to alter its original meaning. I wrote: " Have there been any reported cases in UK? I didn't think anyone had died of accidental plant poisoning (according to the RHS) for a very long time." I was not referring to Nicotiana or any other plant speifically. In that case I misunderstood you - you inserted your reply straight after the Nicotiana comment and I understood you to be referring to that. What exactly is meant by 'the most toxic'? The one which has killed the most? The one with the highest concentration of the poisonous substance? What would be your thinking? Just that it's not easy to answer the question without clarifying the definition. Probably what is meant is the plant which requires least of the plant to kill, but one could argue that something which kills quickly is more toxic than something which takes longer to kill. And the statistics are likely to highlight the ones which have caused most deaths, which are not necessarily the most toxic, because other factors come in, like how common the plant is, how attractive it is, how easily mistaken for edible things, etc. -- Kay |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
Sacha wrote: On 3/12/06 20:20, in article , "luke" wrote: i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Almost certainly Ricinus, the castor bean, the castor oil plant. But when we were in Kauai, Hawaii, we toured a garden and there was one area where nobody was allowed off the bus because ALL the surrounding plants were highly toxic and part of a research project, IIRC. Some of the nastier plants that have mastered organofluorine chemistry that are native to South Africa and Australia are not to be trifled with. See for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluoroacetate But my vote is still for Ricinus seeds. Regards, Martin Brown |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
what is the MOST toxic plant?
Duncan wrote: "luke" wrote in message ups.com... i have been doing research into poisonous plants and i have hit a stone what is the MOST toxic plant in the world. some websites say it is the castor bean some say it is the roseary pea but some people say it deadly nightshade(atropa belladona) i just dont know Castor bean seems a good candidate, but some other nasties include Oleander (said to be able to kill if twigs are used as barbecue skewers) and monkshood (but I'm still here despite my parents having a garden full of this). Alnwick garden have a good poisonous plants collection, and apparently someone was hospitalised after just sniffing the henbane. I am not surprised. I was there on a warm still summers day and the smell of it was unpleasant and overpowering. I had to move away from it while the guide prattled on. but Nicotiana probably kills more than all the other poisonous plants put together. It used to kill the people who smuggled the leaves in olden days (nasty way to go). Regards, Martin Brown |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Most fragrant plant for baskets/patio pots? | United Kingdom | |||
The most toxic town in America (Monsanto) - new "rules" for PCB sites | Gardening | |||
The most toxic town in America (Monsanto) | Gardening | |||
Barton Springs toxic | Texas | |||
Article of toxic levels of arsenic and other chems... | Gardening |