I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

In article ,
Judith in France wrote:
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

95% with "maincrop" broad beans, 99% with fennel, scorzonera and
salsify - and probably also some of my carror sowings.


Regards,
Nick Maclaren.

Judith in France wrote:
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

My runner beans were around 95% successful. They are all beans saved
from previous years. Originally they were from England "Streamline", but
the original packet was probably around 8 years ago!

My only total failure is parsnips. Neither of the two batches sowed (two
months apart) in the garden has germinated, or have do so too slowly
such that they are over-run with weed seedlings. I've just hoed over my
last failed batch. I managed to germinate some in a pot to transplant
out, but the slugs / snails polished the lot off! Score 0 / 3 at the
moment :-( Can't possibly have a Christmas roast dinner without some
parsnips! It would be a disaster and totally ruin Christmas!

--
David in Normandy.
To e-mail you must include the password FROG on the
subject line, or it will be automatically deleted
by a filter and not reach my inbox.

On Jun 13, 12:13*pm, Judith in France
wrote:
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. *Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! *

Yes, English athletics is in a poor state right now.

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

We always sow runner beans in pots outside and transplant them as some
little bugs always eat the seed in the ground. Transplanting is reasonably
quick and almost 100% effective, wind and slugs causing a minimal loss.

www.rraa.moonfruit.com

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

This is my first year of trying to grow things 'seriously' as I'm a newbie
and have a laid-back attitude to gardening failure (it's my normal state of
gardening...) and complete joy at anything that manages to grow.

Runner beans:so many seedlings I gave some away. Ditto for dwarf french
beans. Peas doing well except for 'Kelvedon Wonder' as it isn't.. got quite
a few failures with that one. 'Onward' have been much better. Tomatoes and
squashes are like triffids, taking over everything. Sweet & hot peppers -
lots of growth and flowers, but little pollination & setting of fruits so
far. Onions coming along nicely. Spring onions slow to germinate & grow but
seem to be picking up a bit. Broad beans... going mad. Lots of height,
zillions of flowers and loads of bean pods forming. Swiss chard, beetroot,
kale, kohl rabi, lettuces, carrots, strawbs, all going ok. Garlic developing
well as is parsley, thyme, rosemary, sage, chives and the like. Potatoes are
developing into trees..

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

All my peas & beans I've sown in paper pots filled with compost and kept
inside until developing - then transferred to outside cloche and then
planted out. Worked for me.

Robert (Plymouth) wrote:

We always sow runner beans in pots outside and transplant them as some
little bugs always eat the seed in the ground. Transplanting is
reasonably quick and almost 100% effective, wind and slugs causing a
minimal loss.


Back in England I used to start off the runner beans in individual pots
in the greenhouse. Since living in France I always plant the seeds
directly into the ground with great success. There tends to be some slug
damage to the seedlings despite a scattering of slug pellets, and some
are nibbled right back to the stem, but they seem to grow faster than
the pests eating them. They are now around three feet high with a few
flowering. Maybe they would be a little more advanced with my old
method, but at the moment there is no shortage of other veg to eat in
the garden and by the end of the season we will undoubtedly be sick of
the sight of runner beans anyway. It was always a lot of faff watering
the individual pots and tending them - especially when they get leggy
prior to planting out.

--
David in Normandy.
To e-mail you must include the password FROG on the
subject line, or it will be automatically deleted
by a filter and not reach my inbox.

"Judith in France" wrote ...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Due to am impending trip to SW France we planted our beans in situ out on
the allotment. Have had problems with White Runners (White Lady, 2 from 12)
and Climbing French Beans (Cobra, again 2 from 12).
The Red Runners all came up and so did all but 3 of the Borlotti.
Planted again and am keeping them in the greenhouse so they stay warm and
damp, got 2 more White Lady so far.

The Red runners and Borlotti were fresh seed!
--
Regards
Bob Hobden
just W. of London

On Jun 13, 3:24*pm, "Bob Hobden" wrote:
"Judith in France" *wrote ...I had some runner beans which I brough from England. *Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! *I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Due to am impending trip to SW France we planted our beans in situ out on
the allotment. Have had problems with White Runners (White Lady, 2 from 12)
and Climbing French Beans (Cobra, again 2 from 12).
The Red Runners all came up and so did all but 3 of the Borlotti.
Planted again and am keeping them in the greenhouse so they stay warm and
damp, got 2 more White Lady so far.

The Red runners and Borlotti were fresh seed!
--
Regards
Bob Hobden
just W. of London

Where in SW France Bob? I will take the good advice given here and
start them off in pots next time.

Judith

"Judith in France" wrote
"Bob Hobden" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote ...I had some runner beans which I brough from
England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Due to am impending trip to SW France we planted our beans in situ out on
the allotment. Have had problems with White Runners (White Lady, 2 from
12)
and Climbing French Beans (Cobra, again 2 from 12).
The Red Runners all came up and so did all but 3 of the Borlotti.
Planted again and am keeping them in the greenhouse so they stay warm and
damp, got 2 more White Lady so far.

The Red runners and Borlotti were fresh seed!

Where in SW France Bob? I will take the good advice given here and
start them off in pots next time.

We stayed in a Farmhouse B & B just outside the town of Lafrancaise, nearest
larger town is Moissac. It was a friends 60th birthday so we went for her
party and a holiday.

--
Regards
Bob Hobden
just W. of London

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

For me it's a question of timing and this year I've been lucky. During the
warm spell in May I planted my French climbers (Blue Lake and Hunter) in
compost filled gravel trays, in the greenhouse. They all germinated and are
now in situ. French dwarf beans were planted direct into the soil, at the
same time and these are doing ok, although they germinated 10 days after the
climbers.
However, if we get another cool wet summer, I won't be expecting a crop from
the climbers. -

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

Yes the rabbits grazed mine off!

"Judith in France" wrote in message
...
I had some runner beans which I brough from England. Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

None of the ones we planted on the allotment have germinated. Other [more
experienced] plot holders are also reporting poor germination.

--
Kathy

It's pointless to try and discuss ethics with a spider.

On Jun 13, 6:19*pm, "Bertie Doe" wrote:
"Judith in France" wrote in ...

I had some runner beans which I brough from England. *Only 2 have
germinated, I dug down and the rest have all rotted away! *I bought
some French runner beans here yesterday, put them on wet kitchen roll
and I will leave them like that until they germinate and then plant,
has anyone else had a failure this year?

Judith

For me it's a question of timing and this year I've been lucky. During the
warm spell in May I planted my French climbers (Blue Lake and Hunter) in
compost filled gravel trays, in the greenhouse. They all germinated and are
now in situ. French dwarf beans were planted direct into the soil, at the
same time and these are doing ok, although they germinated 10 days after the
climbers.
However, if we get another cool wet summer, I won't be expecting a crop from
the climbers. -

It's very interesting reading all the replies; it seems some of us
have had mixed results. Next year I will germinate and then plant
out.

Judith