Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. Tater, I think you are spot on with your observation--most of our slaveholding class in the South were former British aristos who were simply re-creating the formula they enjoyed back in the home country. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 3, 10:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I knew several people who were in "service" as it is called. Back then,they were treated like shit. Badly paid with cramped filthy cold accommodation. But everything was tough back then, everyone was treated like shit not just in the UK. Worst of all was the USA where immigrants were lured by false promises and then put in sweatshops etc. Where service exists now (pretty limited) life is a lot better. Before WW2, even quite small households would have a "housekeeper" at least. Even terrace houses. About 25% of the population was employed as servants of some sort. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 3, 4:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. Kate Winslet was good in that Titanic movie. A bit chubby maybe, but really, quite a fine thespian. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 9:20*am, Toby Drake wrote:
On Feb 3, 4:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. Kate Winslet was good in that Titanic movie. A bit chubby maybe, but really, quite a fine thespian. Kate? A thespian? I thought she loved men? :P |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote:
On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 3:31*pm, Wombat wrote:
On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. And fiction often takes liberties with the truth. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. A fine old building in well kept grounds. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. Didn't Cilla Black used to sing about it? |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 2:26*pm, xyzzy wrote:
On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highclere_Castle http://www.highclerecastle.co.uk/vis...ing-times.html The best thing you can do is buy a UK guidebook & have a good read. Then come back with any questions. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 9:31*am, Wombat wrote:
On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. I'm not sure where you're getting your information. It's most definitely 'Downtown Abbey' Please don't comment unless you can be accurate. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 6:06*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
On Feb 4, 9:31*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. I'm not sure where you're getting your information. It's most definitely 'Downtown Abbey' Please don't comment unless you can be accurate. Look it up. Googling Downtown Abbey defaults to Downton Abbey. Methinks 'you' shouldn't comment, unless the name was changed mid- Atlantic. It was Downton Abbey on BBC 1 and Dutch television. |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 11:22*am, Wombat wrote:
On Feb 4, 6:06*pm, Tater Cole wrote: On Feb 4, 9:31*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. I'm not sure where you're getting your information. It's most definitely 'Downtown Abbey' Please don't comment unless you can be accurate. Look it up. *Googling Downtown Abbey defaults to Downton Abbey. Methinks 'you' shouldn't comment, unless the name was changed mid- Atlantic. *It was Downton Abbey on BBC 1 and Dutch television. Ah, well there's the proverbial rub. Obviously, you are ignorant of the fact the name was changed to Downtown Abbey for BBC America. Funny how we Americans spell things slightly different in many ways from the Queen's English: fiber/fibre, color/colour, Downtown/Downton, etc. |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 7:20*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
On Feb 4, 11:22*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 6:06*pm, Tater Cole wrote: On Feb 4, 9:31*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. I'm not sure where you're getting your information. It's most definitely 'Downtown Abbey' Please don't comment unless you can be accurate. Look it up. *Googling Downtown Abbey defaults to Downton Abbey. Methinks 'you' shouldn't comment, unless the name was changed mid- Atlantic. *It was Downton Abbey on BBC 1 and Dutch television. Ah, well there's the proverbial rub. Obviously, you are ignorant of the fact the name was changed to Downtown Abbey for BBC America. Funny how we Americans spell things slightly different in many ways from the Queen's English: fiber/fibre, color/colour, Downtown/Downton, etc. How would I have known that? You are being somewhat impolite. Downtown as the name of a country house is weird. Finishing with a joke on English place names:- Somewhere in England (as the newsreels used to say) there is a direction sign reading "To Old Bolingbroke and Mavis Enderby" to which a wit has appended "the gift of a son". |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 7:20*pm, Tater Cole wrote:
On Feb 4, 11:22*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 6:06*pm, Tater Cole wrote: On Feb 4, 9:31*am, Wombat wrote: On Feb 4, 3:26*pm, xyzzy wrote: On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! Ist, for everyone, the title is Downton Abbey. *It is fiction. 2nd, it was filmed at Highclere Castle in Hampshire. 3rd, Downton is a village in Wiltshire. I'm not sure where you're getting your information. It's most definitely 'Downtown Abbey' Please don't comment unless you can be accurate. Look it up. *Googling Downtown Abbey defaults to Downton Abbey. Methinks 'you' shouldn't comment, unless the name was changed mid- Atlantic. *It was Downton Abbey on BBC 1 and Dutch television. Ah, well there's the proverbial rub. Obviously, you are ignorant of the fact the name was changed to Downtown Abbey for BBC America. Funny how we Americans spell things slightly different in many ways from the Queen's English: fiber/fibre, color/colour, Downtown/Downton, etc. Further to my last mail, from the BBC America site http://www.bbcamerica.com/anglopheni...overns-career/ is the little factoid "Downton Abbey, the hit British series that begins its second season on PBS this Sunday (Jan. 9), has positively pushed the reset button on the career of Elizabeth McGovern". There are many, many other examples. No mention of Downtown. Where did your spelling come from? Game, set and match? |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
I have a question about Downtown Abbey.
On Feb 4, 9:26*am, xyzzy wrote:
On Feb 3, 5:16*pm, Tater Cole wrote: Downtown Abbey is a pretty good program on BBC America. However, actual research suggests that British aristocracy treated most of the domestic class like animals. In fact, I believe some hunting dogs had it much better than your typical laundry maid. Yes, the Butler and Housekeeper were treated with respect, but still, seems like this program is quite inaccurate regarding the Victorian domestic class. Maybe it's simply liberal Brit revisionist history at work again, through the auspices of 'high entertainment' by the BBC. I am cornfused. I wanted to visit Downton Abbey and see some of the Grantham family history. *I Learned on the documentary series that it's in North Yorkshire but google maps has it in Wiltshire. How do you report errors to google maps? Also any travel tips for visiting there would be appreciated. TIA! http://www.yorkpress.co.uk/features/...ownton_Abbey_/ |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Lacock Abbey | Garden Photos | |||
Abbey Gardens, Tresco | United Kingdom | |||
Tresco Abbey Gardens | United Kingdom | |||
Winnipeg gardeners? (West End/St. James/ Downtown) | Gardening | |||
Abbey Garden Nr. Swindon | United Kingdom |